HGB Ep. 652 - Haunted Toronto

Moment in Oddity - Old RIP the Lizard

There is a tradition of encasing items in the cornerstones of new buildings as a symbolic time capsule. This dates back to Egyptian and Mesopotamian times. The usual items encased are newspapers of the day, coins, photographs and documents listing the architects of the building. It is meant to preserve the history of the era for future generations. In 1897, there was a very unique object placed inside the cornerstone of a new courthouse in Eastland, Texas, during its construction. Thirty one years later, on February 18th, 1928, the courthouse was torn down and the cornerstone was opened before a large crowd. What was found inside was a flat, dusty lizard that was showing signs of life! Let me introduce you to 'Old RIP'. RIP was a Texas Horned Lizard, the species is also often called horny-toad or horned toad. At the time of the encasement, there was a local folklore belief that horned lizards could hibernate for over a century without air, food or water. The county clerk of Eastland decided to test that theory with his son's young lizard named 'Blinky'. The clerk sealed the pet inside the cornerstone of the new courthouse. Upon emerging from the cornerstone, Ol' RIP was renamed for Rip Van Winkle. The lizard became a famous national celebrity. He even traveled across the country to visit President Calvin Coolidge at the White House. Sadly, the celebrity lizard died just under a year later from pneumonia on January 19th, 1929. His little body was embalmed, placed in a small velvet-lined casket, and put on permanent display in the new Eastland County Courthouse. Time capsules can be an interesting and fun look into the past. But encasing a live lizard who emerges alive 31 years later, certainly is odd. 

Haunted Toronto

Canada is home to some great haunts and Toronto is one of those cities harboring several locations with ghosts stories. We've covered Keg Mansion (Ep. 303) and Queen's Park (Ep. 57 & upcoming Redux) in previous episodes, but there are many other haunted locations in the city of Toronto and on this episode, we are going to explore several of them. There are theaters and jails, but also several little shops and restaurants that seem warm and inviting until one realizes you may be joined by the unseen. Join us for the history and hauntings of the city of Toronto.

Toronto was originally settled by the Wyandot (WHY-an-dot) People and then the Iroquois. A Frenchman named Etienne Brule (ay-TYEN broo-LAY) was the first to explore the area in 1615 and that is why the French would be the first Europeans to settle. Brûlé served as an interpreter and guide for Samuel de Champlain. As an aside, Brûlé would later betray his native France, helping the English capture Quebec City. This same kind of behavior against the Huron people, with whom he lived later, would lead the Huron to stab and dismember him and then eat him. The first European settlement was established in 1750 as a French trading fort known as Fort Rouille (roo-ee). In 1787, the Toronto Purchase happened and this was basically the Mississaugas (missuh-SAW-guh) tribe giving up the land to the British Crown. In 1793, the Town of York was established by Governor John Graves Simcoe, named for Prince Frederick, who was the Duke of York. It would be the capital of Upper Canada. The first post office opened here in 1833 and the name was changed to Toronto in 1834 when the city was incorporated. Toronto came from the Mohawk word tkaronto, which means "where there are trees standing in the water. Gas street lights were added in 1841 and the city grew and flourished. The railroad would come, as well as horse drawn streetcars that eventually were electrified. In 1867, Toronto became the capital of Ontario. The city would suffer its own great fire in 1904 and the Depression would hit it hard, but following World War II, the city rose to prominence. Today, it is the most populous city in Canada

The Grange

The Grange is the 12th oldest building in Toronto and was built in 1817 in the Georgian style for D'Arcy Boulton who was a well known resident of the city and came from a powerful family in the city. The name came from the family's property of the same name in England. The house was two storeys and made from bricks formed on the land. The front door opened into a central hall with a dining room, drawing room and bedrooms on the first floor and bedrooms on the second floor. The attic had servant rooms. The kitchen and scullery were in the basement. 

D'Arcy and his wife Sarah Anne had eight children. Their home became the social center for Toronto for a time and D'Arcy made a living running a dry goods store. When he passed in 1846, the house passed to his William Henry Boulton and his wife Hariette. William was the mayor of Toronto at the time. He died in 1874 and he left the house to his wife Hariette who remarried to a prominent scholar named Goldwin Smith. The house was bequeathed to the Art Museum of Toronto in 1910. The St. George Church was also on the property as the Boultons founded it, but it burned down in 1956, leaving only the tower and Sunday school building. The grounds became Grange Park. The house was restored in the 1960s and eventually renamed the Art Gallery of Ontario. Today, the Grange houses the Norma Ridley Members' Lounge and exhibit spaces and tours are offered, although it isn't furnished as a museum. Visitors and staff have seen a man in a yellow velvet coat that likes to roam the hallways. He has been witnessed walking straight through solid walls in the conservatory where it is believed there used to be some doors that are no longer there. A woman in black hangs out near a second-floor bedroom. The ground floor kitchen has a lady in white haunting it. People believe the ghosts of Goldwin Smith and weird fiction writer Algernon Blackwood are in the house. Blackwood had visited the house several times as he was friends with Smith.

Humber Polytechnic's Lakeshore Campus

Humber College's Lakeshore Campus is next to the shores of Lake Ontario and is part of Humber Polytechnic. This campus is one of three and was established in 1967. There is a lot of interesting architecture as it sits on the grounds of the former Lakeshore Psychiatric Hospital and Lakeshore Teachers' College. And interesting art like the sculpture of Persephone created by Harley Valentine in 2013. The Greek queen of the underworld was placed in the front plaza of the L-Building, which opened in 2011. There are several cottages around the L-Building. The psychiatric hospital was built in 1888 and originally named the Mimico Asylum. The cottages are left over from the asylum that was designed in the cottage system. The buildings and cottage were done in the Gothic and Romanesque style. The patients helped to build most of the buildings and they worked the farm on the grounds. This was basically forced labor. There was overcrowding and some mistreatment and violence among the patients. The hospital had a cemetery, which contained the bodies of 1,511 patients, most of them unmarked. It remains about a mile away from the hospital. There was a big renovation in 1959, but when another was needed in 1979, the decision was made to close the hospital. The hospital made appearances in most of the Police Academy movies and recently in 2020, it was the setting for the Matheson Academy on Netflix's Locke & Key. Humber College began leasing the property in 1991 and renovated the building and cottages. 

A story claims that a nurse hanged herself on an apple tree near the hospital and makes appearances as a ghost now. She has been seen walking the halls at night. Strange scents are reported in the F Building that had once housed the morgue. In the cottages, objects move on their own and chairs roll on their own. Phantom handprints have been seen on the windows.  

Chris Kelterborn was a community and justice services student who wrote when asked if he experienced anything weird in the residence hall, "F**k yes, toiletries randomly flying off the shelves, cutlery randomly clattering in the sink and lights turning on and off at random." Cece Courtemanche, another student, reported the following from her time in the residence hall in 2015, "Yeah, I do have a couple stories, definitely the weirdest one though was that I used to constantly hear stomping sounds, almost like someone running, nearly every night without fail, at 3am. Just someone running on the floor above me. And it wasn’t just me, other people on my floor heard it too. But the part that didn’t make any sense was the running would only ever happen at 3am. It was so bizarre, and to this day I don’t have any sort of explanation for it!" Another student said that random stuff would disappear from their kitchen and be missing for days and then in one case, they found the spatula in the middle of the room on the floor. 

Dentistry Building on the George Brown Campus

George Brown founded the Toronto Globe and was one of the Fathers of Confederation. The college was named for him and established in 1967. The dentistry facilities were located at the Casa Loma Campus before moving to the Waterfront Campus. This left a building abandoned and apparently, it had some paranormal activity.

Snoo22214 wrote on Reddit, "Used to go in there all the time on official business. Its dangerous to be in there, so you have to go with someone. We rounded a corner and saw someone standing in the hall watching us. They vanished into thin air. We decided to call the visit short after that. Phone calls also come from that building from a woman despite the phones being disconnected." Random flushing in the empty building was a thing. Another comment from Reddit reads, "I hated that building so much! I worked security at GBC long time ago and that was part of our daily patrols. Luckily I never saw anyone but I would always hear random toilet flushing and felt like I was being watched the whole time. Scary!" 

Colborne Lodge 

The Colborne Lodge is a unique looking cottage nestled in High Park that was built in 1837 by Toronto architect and High Park founder John Howard and his wife Jemima. The two were painters and quite eccentric and they filled the home with their art, drawings and inventions that still remain today. The style of the cottage is Regency Picturesque and the exterior is stuccoed. 

Jemima became the first documented case of breast cancer in the city of Toronto and rather than help his wife to battle the disease, Howard tried to have her committed to a Provincial Lunatic Asylum. The Asylum denied the request, so he locked in her room where she stayed until her death in 1877. She spent most days looking out the window, which faced the tomb he had built for the couple to share. The couple gifted the property to the City of Toronto upon their deaths. The ghost here is believed to be Jemima, who has been seen standing at a bedroom window. The first person to record seeing this was a police officer patrolling the park in 1969. He went into the house thinking someone had broken in and he found it empty. There are also reports of phantom soldiers in the park, although we don't know what that would be from. Perhaps a very early squirmish?

Gibraltar Point Lighthouse

We love lighthouses around here and they all seem to harbor ghost stories it seems. Gibraltar Point Lighthouse is no different. There was a long, finger-like peninsula that extended out into Lake Ontario from Toronto and this formed a natural harbor that needed defending. Fort York was built for this purpose - we'll get into that location next - and John Graves Simcoe, who was the first Lieutenant Governor of Upper Canada, named the peninsula Gibraltar Point. This was probably wishful thinking for Simcoe as he wanted to give the impression that it was "fortified so as to be impregnable." 

A blockhouse was built on the point with Fort York across from it. A few years later, in 1803, the Parliament of Upper Canada decided to put a lighthouse on Gibraltar Point. The lighthouse was completed in 1808 and is today, the oldest standing lighthouse on the Great Lakes. The lighthouse was constructed from limestone and built in a hexagonal shape and was 52 feet when finished. In 1832, it was raised to 82 feet. Simcoe was wrong about the point being fortified as the lighthouse actually helped guide American forces in an attack on Toronto. The first keeper was John P. Radelmuller (Radel mule er) and he would end up being the first death here. And, it was murder. The York Gazette reported on January 14, 1815, "Died on the evening of the 2nd of January, J.P. Radelmuller, keeper of the lighthouse on Gibraltar Point. From circumstances there is moral proof of his having been murdered. If the horrid crime admits of aggravation when the inoffensive and benevolent character of the unfortunate sufferer are considered, his murder will be pronounced most barbarous and inhuman. The parties lost with him are the proposed perpetrators and are in prison." The York Gazette reported three months later, "No conviction of the supposed murderers of the late J.P. Radelmuller." Unfortunately, these accounts give no details as to what happened, but tradition holds that soldiers from the York garrison came to the lighthouse for beer. Radelmuller was making bootleg beer in his free time and he either refused to sell to them or overcharged and they got angry and killed him. He disappeared and was never seen again. The next keepers would be James Durnan and his son George and they worked there until 1905. They often talked of the murder and even claimed to have found a human jaw bone. In 1915, the lighthouse got its fourth-order Fresnal lens and was electrified in 1917. Before this, the lighthouse went through a time using candles, then sperm oil and coal. With electrification, the light's last keeper, Blake Matthews, left in 1918. The flashing white light became green in 1945. The light was deactivated in 1959 and replaced by a tripod tower with a red flashing light. There had been a keeper's cottage here that was built in 1808 with the lighthouse, but it was demolished in 1950. Occasional tours are offered.

Reports of ghost stories go way back and the CBC even ran a special back in 1958 about the stories. They said there were hundreds of reports of ghostly happenings in and around the light. There were strange blood stains that would show up on the staircase. There were unexplained lights in the windows and shadowy figures seen. Many visitors have claimed to see Radelmüller’s ghost climbing the tower, probably in search for his body parts.

Fort York

And as we just mentioned, Gibraltar Point had Fort York, which is today known as Fort York National Historic Site. The first permanent fort was built in 1793 and was mainly a bunch of cabins. Two log barracks were added and then a stockade and sawmill. The following year, two blockhouses were built and a guard house. In 1798, many original buildings were replaced and a stockade was built around the property. Artillery batteries were added as were furnaces so that fire heated shot could be used. This is where British soldiers, First Nations warriors and Upper Canadian militiamen tried to hold the Town of York, which was Toronto's original name, against an American attack during the War of 1812. The Battle of York took place on April 27, 1813 and was a defeat for the British and Canadians. The British were led by Major General Roger Hale Sheaffe and they were outnumbered by the American led by Major General Henry Dearborn. The Americans had an entire Naval flotilla with them, numbering 14 ships. Not only were Sheaffe's forces outnumbered, but a company of Glengarry Light Infantry got lost on the outskirts of York and were unable to assist the Native tribes who were where the Americans were landing. Fort York was heavily bombarded and Sheaffe soon decided that the battle was lost, so he ordered the regulars to retreat and they set fire to a wooden bridge over the River Don so that the Americans couldn't pursue them. The militia was left behind with many of the citizens of York. They were described in the paper as "standing in the street like a parcel of sheep." Sheaffe told the militia to try to get the best terms they could with the Americans. He also had the HMS Sir Isaac Brock that was under construction at the York Naval Shipyard burned. The magazine was also blown up, which caused a large number of American casualties. Even after Sheaffe vacated the fort, the Americans kept firing because the British left their flag up as a ruse. The Americans had 320 casualties to Britain's 475. York was burned and plundered and the Americans occupied it for two weeks. As the Americans left York, they burned the structures in the fort, except for the barracks. The fort was rebuilt in 1813 and was in use until 1932 with many years of peace leading to decay and many years of preparing for hostilities leading to refurbishment. Fort York officially was handed over to Canada in 1870 by the British. The fort was reopened as a museum on Victoria Day in 1934. Recently, the fort hosted the 2026 Toronto FIFA Fan Festival. 

Fort York embraces its haunts. They occasionally host evening lantern tours, especially around Halloween. There is a soldier wearing a red coat that is seen near the fort's entrance and one of the old barracks. Unexplained noises are heard as well as disembodied footsteps and whispers. Cold spots are felt. A female spirit is seen roaming around the Officer's Quarters. And the ghost of Lt. Zachariah Mudge is said to be roaming about because he unalived himself in 1831 and was denied a proper Christian burial. Visitors and staff claim to get the eerie feeling of being watched.  

Elgin and Winter Garden Theatre

Elgin and Winter Garden Theaters are a pair of theatres that were built as the flagship of Marcus Loew's theatre chain in 1913. Architect Thomas W. Lamb designed them as Edwardian double-decker theaters and they started with vaudeville and short silent movies. The Elgin Theater was originally named Loew's Yonge Street Theater and had a gold-and-marble, domed, hard-top theater. This was the lower theater. Winter Garden was the upper theater and was set up as an atmospheric theater. The interior resembled a country garden under the stars, painted with murals of plants and garden trellises. There were lantern lights and the columns were designed like tree trunks. In 1928, the Elgin was converted into a sound theater for the new Talkies. The Winter Garden was closed at that time and stayed closed for 60 years. In 1969, Loews sold the Elgin to Famous Players and by the 1970s, the Elgin was showing mainly B movies and soft-core pornography. The Ontario Heritage Foundation bought the structure from Famous Players in 1981. The 1980s brought improvement with real theater. Cats ran here from 1985 to 1987 and was very successful. restoration was done to both theaters in 1987 and they reopened in 1989.

There are disembodied footsteps up in the balconies and doors open and close by themselves. There is a story that a girl allegedly was stabbed in the Winter Garden washroom on the 5th floor and she managed to drag herself to the elevator before she died on the floor. Today, staff and guests say the elevator travels by itself to the fifth floor. And they think she is a ghost they nicknamed the Lavender Lady who leaves behind the scent of lavender. The Winter Garden is haunted by Sam the Trombone Player who is said to be a friendly ghost.

Massey Hall

Massey Hall is one of Toronto’s most beloved concert venues. Hart Massey was a Canadian businessman and philanthropist who built the Massey Ferguson agricultural equipment firm. He decided he wanted to build a music hall that was secular and this was the Massey Music Hall, which was built in the neoclassical design with Moorish arches under the direction of architect Sidney Badgley. the interior was inspired by the Alhambra Palace in Spain. The hall was completed in 1894 and debuted with a choral performance of Handel's Messiah. A bar was opened in the basement in 1994 to commemorate the hall's 100th anniversary. There was a major renovation in 2013 and a new addition was added in 2022. The place has hosted musical performances, political speeches, speaking tours, memorials and even boxing. The future King George V and his wife Queen Mary visited in 1901. 

There have been various reports of spectral visitors. One of these spirits is a man in period clothing who wanders around the backstage area. People believe this man may be a custodian who had lived in an apartment behind the stage. A ghostly elderly couple have been spotted in the aisles late at night. And there is a female ghost who may belong to an opera singer that likes to watch performances from the audience. She seems to like it when a soprano takes the stage.

Old City Hall

Toronto's Old City Hall was one of the largest buildings in Toronto when it was completed in 1899. It was designed by Edward James Lennox in the Richardsonian Romanesque style and took a decade to complete and cost over $2 million. This is a magnificent building made from several types of stone: sandstone, grey stone and brown stone. This is an enormous Square quad with a courtyard in the middle and a tall clock tower that is slightly off center. There were carvings of animals and humans all along the exterior of the building. Three large oak doorways lead into a two-storey main hall with murals and stained-glass windows. This was the city's grandest interior space at the time. Lennox made sure to have the stonemasons put his name in corbels under the upper floor eaves because the councilors of the city were angry with cost overruns and wouldn't allow a plaque to be added to the building proclaiming him as the architect. Four gargoyles were part of the Clock Tower when it was finished, but they had to be removed due to erosion in 1938. Bronze casts of the gargoyles were reinstalled in 2002. The city hall proved to be inadequate so a new one was built in 1965. The old one was supposed to be demolished and replaced with a retail building, but community outcry saved it and it became a dedicated courthouse. The courts have since moved and the city is still working on its next steps. It probably will be a temporary home for the Ontario Legislative Assembly.

Judges claimed to feel mysterious tugs at their robes by things they couldn't see. Disembodied footsteps have been heard, especially at the building’s rear staircase. For some reason, muffled moans are heard coming from the attic. Ronald Turpin and Arthur Lucas were sentenced and charged here in Courtroom 125 (formerly 33) and were the last two Canadians executed in Canada. Their ghosts are said to haunt the courtroom. In John Robert Colombo’s book Haunted Toronto, he tells of a pair of reporters that almost managed to spend the night but gave in by 4am. But then the reporters experienced what they described as “cool fogs” and weird noises that left them, at times, glued to the floor and they decided to pack up and leave. 

Christie Mansion

William Mellis Christie was known as the cookie baron. He had emigrated from Scotland to Canada when he was a teenager in 1848. In Scotland, he had been an apprentice to a baker and so he quickly found work in a bakery in Ontario. At night, he would bake bread and then sell it from a handcart in the mornings. This grew into his own company and then he partnered with his old boss to form Christie, Brown and Company and they opened up a factory that took up an entire block. Christie won multiple awards for his cookies. By the end of the 1800s, Christie employed two out of every three people in biscuit making in Canada. He built a fortune and then built his mansion across from Queen's Park. Christie died of cancer in 1900 and the mansion passed on to his son Robert. And apparently, Robert had a secret. There is a legend that claims that Robert had a mistress and that he had the audacity to keep her at the mansion in a secret room located behind wood paneling in the library. A servant was bribed to take food to the mistress and keep quiet about the arrangement. After awhile, Robert got bored with the woman and ignored her and she became despondent and hanged herself from a rafter with a bedsheet. Robert moved the body out under the cover of darkness and rumors claim the mistress was buried over at Queen's Park. The guilt whittled away at Robert and he soon was in the grave. And the Christie cookies were bought by Nabisco. The mansion became home to the local chapter of the Sisters of St. Joseph’s. Today, it's Regis College, the Jesuit School of Theology affiliated with the University of Toronto.

The ghost of the mistress is said to haunt the mansion. The door to the former secret room slams shut by itself and would lock itself, trapping students inside. The mansion eventually became a female dorm for University of Toronto students, and there have been reports of a spirit haunting the mistress’s hidden room. An uneasy presence is felt in the room, that is referred to as Room 29. While no one can find evidence that the mistress story is true, there is really a secret room built into the framework of the building. 

Mackenzie House (Covered on a BonusCast)

The second occurrence of a ghost being listed in an official government document, happened in relation to Mackenzie House in Toronto. This is reputed to be the most haunted house in Toronto. It was once the home of firebrand and reformer William Lyon Mackenzie. He died in the home. And apparently, his spirit never left. 

The name Mackenzie comes from Clan MacKenzie of Scotland. This was one of the most powerful clans during the 17th Century. One of their members was William Lyon Mackenzie who was the first Mayor of Toronto. He had been born in Dundee, Scotland in 1795 and he emigrated to Canada when he was twenty-five. Mackenzie got involved in politics and served in the Legislative Assembly of Upper Canada. He aligned with the Reformers who were seeking to get corruption out of the government. This activity led to the Upper Canada Rebellion, which ended in defeat for the rebels. Since Mackenzie had been a leader, he was forced into exile in the US where he resided until 1850. He returned to Canada penniless and his friends helped him to purchase the Mackenzie House. Mackenzie lived there with his family until his death in 1861. His wife and daughters continued to live in the house for ten more years even though it was seized by the Sheriff of Toronto because of unpaid financial obligations. Another man named John Taylor bought the property and allowed the Mackenzies to stay. Mackenzie's wife Isabel was able to buy back the house four years later. The Mackenzie House was located at 82 Bond Street and was one of several row houses on the street. It stood two stories and was designed in the Georgian architectural style. In 1936 when William Lyon Mackenzie King, Mackenzie’s grandson, was Prime Minister, the house was saved from demolition when its neighboring row houses were destroyed. By the 1940s, the house was being renovated into a museum and that's what it is today. The site features furniture from the nineteenth century, an 1845 printing press and artifacts from its former print shop. When the house was being converted, various caretakers resided in it and that's when the first reports of ghostly activity started.

There were many a story told of the ghost that lived in MacKenzie House. People heard footsteps creaking on the stairs and playing of the piano. Spirits were seen standing over those who were sleeping. Mackenzie’s body is buried at Toronto Necropolis, but some believe his spirit returns to his former home. The apparition of a small, bald man in a wig and frock coat is often seen around the home, especially in the third floor bedroom. This would be an apt description of the former famous occupant. 

Also, a woman with long hair has been spotted around the second and third floor areas. Cold spots and poltergeist activity have occurred. The printing press in the basement starting up on its own has been reported by the staff and many of the tourists. Apparently, one of the more interesting things is the ghosts' reported near obsession with something that is relatively new in the house, the indoor plumbing. One of the caretakers in the 1950s was named Mrs. Edmunds. Mrs. Edmund one night claimed that she was awoken by a soft touch on the shoulder. When she opened her eyes, Mrs. Edmund said there was a lady there bending over her, looking into her face. But a few seconds later, the lady vanished. A few weeks later, Mrs. Edmund claims it happened again, but this time, Mrs. Edmund said the lady drew back her hand and slapped her in the face before vanishing. In 1960, this house was donated to the City of Toronto. Part of this bequest was an inventory of all the artifacts that were in the house at that time and at the bottom of this list were the words, ‘One ghost. It was then decided to try to exorcise the house. A blessing was performed on the house in 1960 by Anglican Archdeacon John Frank to remove any spirits who were currently residing there. The haunting activity has continued, so it apparently didn't work. The Toronto Daily Star ran an article on June 28, 1960, which derided the allegations: “Ghosts in Toronto? No, ghost writers.” It quoted officials from the Mackenzie Homestead Foundation, which then owned and operated the house as a museum, as admitting they “dreamed up” the story with the Telegram to drum up interest. Caretaker Alex Dobban appeared to backtrack on the tales of spirits, telling a Star reporter, “There’s nothing to it.”

A seance was held two days after this story with seven spiritualists and they said, "The guest of honor failed to show up. He wasn’t even there in spirit." Medium Harold Hilton told the Star, "This proves definitely that the Mackenzie House isn’t haunted." In 1988, Toronto Star reporter Catherine Dunphy visited the house with the psychic Elizabeth Paddon and a professor who was a paranormal investigator named Ian Currie. Paddon apparently went into a trance and became the medium for the spirit of Mackenzie’s wife, Isabel Baxter Mackenzie. Currie claimed to have convinced her to move on to the world where her husband awaited.

Spadina (Spa dine ah) House

The Spadina House was once a sprawling country estate built for Dr. William Warren Baldwin in 1818. The original house burned down and had to be rebuilt in 1836. Baldwin called his estate Spadina after the Ojibwe word Ishpadinaa, which means "sudden rise of land." This was fitting as the house sat on top of a steep slope. The founder of The Dominion Bank, James Austin, bought the house in 1866 and 80 acres of the original 200 acres. The area had grown into the wealthiest neighborhood in Toronto. James gave the house to his son Albert in 1892. Albert added a third floor to the house in 1912. Albert's daughter Anna Thompson inherited the house and she lived in it from 1942 until 1982. The family donated the house and all its furnishings to the city of Toronto. The house opened as a museum in 1984 and features a mix of architectural style, Victorian, Edwardian and Italianate. The keystones feature botanical themes and the property is known for its gardens. The central hall has a floating staircase and there are 55 rooms. Stuffed wolves were found in the family's archives and they have been placed at the entryway of the museum.  

The Toronto & Ontario Ghosts and Hauntings Research Society claims that visitors and staff have seen a foggy grayish apparition that darts around the children’s bedrooms and in the hallway on the third floor. No one died in the house, but people wonder if this apparition might the spirit of one of the wolves. They think this because the wolves were sent off for restoration and when they were returned, that is when the gray mass started showing up.

Don Jail

The Old Don Jail was designed by architect William Thomas with directions to model it after the Pentonville Prison in London. The jail was done in the Renaissance Revival style and completed in 1864 from bricks out of the Toronto brickyards and stone from quarries from Ohio. Thomas incorporated an innovative heating and cooling system that consisted of a network of ducts and flues and two ventilation towers. This was the largest reform jail facility in North America when it opened and it eventually became notorious for poor treatment of the prisoners. It started out with inmates sleeping in small cells and working during the days on an industrial farm or in workshops and this trained them for better lives after release. Over time, this switched away from work programs and inmates would just be stuck in their cramped cells all day with more than one inmate in a cell at times. The overcrowding led to illnesses like tuberculosis sweeping through and the entire facility was vermin infested. There were executions conducted here with 34 hangings that included Ronald Turpin and Arthur Lucas who were hanged side by side in 1962 as the last executions in Canada. A new modern wing was added in 1958, bringing the capacity of the jail up to 550 inmates. The doors closed in 1977, with the new wing staying open until 2013, and the building was used for storage until Bridgepoint Health commissioned the complex for restoration as a new healthcare center in 2012. They transformed the place into welcoming and functional administrative space with modern office spaces. There are self-guided tours offered during the week with 10 cells restored to their original state. 

Some of the famous inmates here were from the bank-robbing Boyd Gang and the Polka Dot Gang. This crew got their nickname from the bandanas they wore as masks. The committed a bunch of violent break-ins and payroll robberies in 1945. There are supposedly several ghosts here, two of which are Ronald Turpin and Arthur Lucas. There is also an agitated blonde woman who wears a white gown and floats or paces around the second level of the central rotunda. She was an inmate here in the 19th-century who died by suicide in the women's west wing. Disembodied cries are heard as well as phantom noises. 

Opposite_Smile6780 wrote on Reddit, "I worked at the Toronto Jail from '08 til its closing in 2013. When they were refurbishing the Don Jail (original building from 1865) for Bridgepoint hospital, we would sometimes go inside the building on lunch break to look around. Definitely eerie. I've had quite a few experiences. On night shift, the kitchen was closed and locked. It was located in the basement of the building and many times while I was standing outside the kitchen waiting on the elevator, I would hear sounds from the kitchen, specifically that sound of the floor drains throughout the kitchen. They made a certain noise if you stepped on one and I would hear that exact sound in the locked kitchen. When 1 of the murders happened inside, there was one in particular who liked to show up. Inmates would tell me stories of seeing this particular inmate pass by the cell doors at night, make noise etc. I had no previous issues with the deceased inmate, always got a long. One day I'm working the unit he was murdered. I was in the control room and mind you, the control room doors where not flimsy. They were fairly heavy and had to be shut forcefully. So I'm standing there looking into the living unit and the door is open behind me and suddenly it starts to slowly creep its way closed. I watched for a second and then said out loud "knock it off insert inmates name" And the door stopped. Early morning shift, unit is still in night mode, inmates are all sleeping and I'm working alone in a very dimly lit area. There was a secure walkway around the entire perimeter of the living unit, where our desk was located and since we were still running in night mode, inmates must remain locked within their cells, within the living unit. As I sat at my desk doing some paperwork, I saw movement out of the corner of my eye down the hall to my right. I saw a full figured (though unidentifiable as the figure didn't have face) apparition dressed all in orange, turn the corner and begin walking down the hall toward me. I panicked because there should not be any inmates out at all within the living unit, let alone the secure area where I was and I whipped my head around and stood up, there was nobody there. There was nothing but a hallway with brown tile and walls of blue and white. One lone light at the end of the hall casting a horrible white light. NOTHING orange. Nothing that I could explain why I saw anything orange in my peripheral. I a few units, some more than others, I would often see shadow people within the groups of inmates I was in charge of that day." 

Hockey Hall of Fame

The former president of the Canadian Amateur Hockey Association, James T. Sutherland, established the Hockey Hall of Fame in Kingston, Ontario in 1943. The point of the Hall of Fame was to honor great hockey players and raise funds for a permanent building. They weren't able to get the funds and the NHL pulled their support until the project moved to Toronto in 1958. 

The first Hall of Fame shared a building with the Canadian Sports Hall of Fame. By 1986, it was outgrowing its space and needed a new place. This place would be one of the former locations of the Bank of Montreal. That building at Front and Yonge Street was built in 1885 by Darling & Curry in the Beaux-Arts style. The Hockey Hall of Fame moved into it in 1993. The HHOF is the home of the Stanley Cup today. 

And it is home to a ghost reputedly. People have experienced doors opening and closing on their own, lights doing their own thing and the disembodied sounds of a woman. The spirit that haunts this location goes by the name Dorothy. The Star researched the back story on Dorothy and found some real evidence. They believe she was named Dorothea Mae Elliott and was a 19-year-old who shot herself in 1953. She survived long enough to make it to the hospital where she died 22 hours later. There were inferences  that she was sad over a broken love affair. Her boyfriend had left to work on the boats.

The Toronto Star reported in 2009, "In the early 1990s, a few years before the Hockey Hall of Fame moved into the historic building that had been a Bank of Montreal branch for close to 100 years, Toronto musician Joanna Jordan saw a female ghost looking down on her from a second-floor ceiling. Jordan, who was playing the harp at an event being held in the building’s Great Hall, was unaware at the time that a ghost purportedly haunted the space. 'I remember it so vividly,' she says, 'because it’s one of those things you’ll never forget.' Jordan refused to go up to the second floor by herself when she played at the Hall, which opened in 1993, some years later. 'It was just too spooky up there.'" And also, "Rob Hynes, who formerly worked at the Hall as a special events supervisor, had an encounter that spooked him. While preparing for an event, he entered a narrow kitchen that runs behind a second-floor conference room to get some coffee urns at around 6 a.m. A strong feeling, as if being watched by someone, 'but different than that,' enticed him to enter the conference room, which was in darkness. 'One of the chairs, and this is the God’s honest truth, was turning, as if a breeze was in there,' he says. 'It actually moved right into my hand. I’m rather skeptical about ghosts, but I just freaked out and ran out of there.' Despite all the reports, only one other person is believed to have actually seen the spirit. One summer a young boy was visiting the Hall of Fame when he started screaming, 'Don’t you see her, don’t you see her,' says Jane Rodney, who was the Hall’s coordinator of resource center services at the time. 'He claimed a woman with long black hair was going in and out of the walls.'" 

Toronto is a city full of history and historic buildings. The residents have made an effort to preserve many of their old spaces and that is a wonderful thing. Hopefully the spirits appreciate this. Are these locations in Toronto haunted? That is for you to decide!