Moment in Oddity - The Thetis Lake Monster
The Thetis Lake Monster remains one of the Pacific Northwest's most peculiar pop-culture pranks. In the summer of 1972, a pair of teenagers terrified the town by claiming a scaly, silver-skinned specimen suddenly surged from the swirling surf of Vancouver Island's scenic sanctuary. According to their tall tale, this beastly bi-pedal, bore brow-spikes and wicked, webbed claws as it disrupted the usually peaceful and popular park. While the bizarre story briefly baffled the local police, researchers later uncovered the truth. The boys had completely fabricated the monster, shamelessly pinching the plot from a cheesy, B-movie, creature feature they had watched on television just days before, titled 'Monsters from the Surf. A low budget Hollywood movie prop holding a community's fear and receptive imagination at bay, certainly is odd.
Haunted McHenry County, Illinois
McHenry County in Illinois sits next to the Chicago metropolitan area with Woodstock as its county seat. It was formed in 1836 and named for Major William McHenry, a member of the Illinois Militia and Illinois House of Representatives and Senate. There are many historic sites within the county still standing that have ghost stories connected to them. The Stickney House was home to Spiritualists who had it designed specifically with no right angles to facilitate the movement of spirits. The Dole Mansion, which was once owned by a Ringling family member, became a country club. There is the haunted mansion of a count and a haunted guest house. Join us as we explore the history and hauntings of McHenry County, Illinois!
The Stickney House
The Stickney House is one of the oldest brick buildings located in Bull Valley, Illinois. Bull Valley is surrounded by some of the largest hills in the area and is known as horse country. The village was known for trying to establish itself as a rural community and has made great efforts to retain that small town feel with nearly no government infrastructure. There are no retail businesses in the town and no electric street lamps. The little bit of government organized in Bull Valley, keeps its offices in the Stickney House. George Washington Stickney was born in New Hampshire in 1809. He moved from New York to the Bull Valley area in 1835. He married a woman named Sylvia Beckley in 1839. They built a log cabin in the Illinois wilderness at that time and as they prospered, they were able to begin construction on a much larger home in 1849. They liked the wilderness not only for farming, but also they wanted to avoid the typical town gossip and prying eyes. The Stickneys were Spiritualists and although they lived during a time in the 1800s when that form of spirituality was becoming more popular, they wanted to have their privacy.
The Stickney House was built in the style of an English country home and although today it would not necessarily be thought of as a mansion, it was at the time. The house was two-stories with the exterior featuring Italianate details, including brick pilasters, arched windows with wooden tracery, a leaded-glass fanlight over the front door, and a front porch supported by Doric columns with a balcony overhead.
The interior featured double parlors on the first floor and bedrooms. The second floor was almost entirely a grand, full-length ballroom. That made this mansion really different, especially considering this was rural Illinois. Typically, the bedrooms would be on a second floor and a full length ballroom would be on a third floor. But what made this mansion even more unique was that it was built with rounded corners, except for one that was a mistake. There was a reason for the design.
No one knows for sure what inspired the Stickneys to get involved with Spiritualism, but the greatest pull was the desire to communicate with the spirits of dead loved ones. Specifically their children. The couple had ten children, but only three of them survived to adulthood. The large ballroom was not built for dancing. Large seances were held in the ballroom and the Stickneys invited people from the surrounding communities. It is believed that they built their house with rounded corners to facilitate the movement of spirits. The Stickneys may have believed that spirits could get trapped in a 90 degree corner. We've discussed this idea when talking about mirrors. Many cultures believe that rounded surfaces keep evil spirits away. The Shakers were building round barns in the early 1800s for this reason. The Chinese built houses with curved eaves to block evil spirits.
Many of the theories that paranormal investigators and ghost television shows espouse about ghosts, come out of spiritualist beliefs. One of those is the idea that negative entities can be the spirits of people who were mean and nasty during their lifetimes and not just evil spirits. This is part of the idea that we carry our personality with us into the afterlife.
The core of Spiritualism is the belief that we can communicate with the dead. And that is the essence of paranormal investigation. Sylvia Stickney was believed to be a very accomplished medium. Of course, the term accomplished is relative. Mediumship has its roots in ancient times, but it became popular during the 19th century and as Houdini helped to prove, much of the spirit communication going on was fraud. There is no information about the type of techniques used by the Stickneys, but they could have included table tipping, channeling, levitation and using talking boards. The Stickney House served other purposes in its time. During the Civil War, the Union used the house as a headquarters. It also had the first piano to be found in McHenry County. George died in 1897. We read several websites that claimed that Sylvia outlived George, but we also found a site that claimed George was widowed and remarried. The 1880 census makes it clear that George was a widower. Sylvia's grave marker records her death in 1879. Records indicate that George remarried to a woman named Lavina Congdon. We're not sure what happened to the house directly after George's death. We know it was abandoned for certain time periods. Roderick Smith moved into the house in the 1970s and he would be the first to report hauntings in the house. Another couple bought the house in hopes of restoring it, but their money came to an end and the restoration did not happen. In 1985, the house became the property of the local government and now houses some government offices and the Bull Valley Police Department. It has been registered as a historic landmark. A 1991 article in the Chicago Tribune reported that Mary Hill and Verna Hogan were heading up efforts to restore the house back to the way it was when the Stickneys lived there and that they estimated it would cost several hundreds of thousands of dollars.
There are some who believe that the Stickneys were not into Spiritualism because the craze was before they moved into their mansion in Bull Valley. The history is so muddled here because some records would put the house being built a year after the Fox Sisters started becoming a sensation. But other records claim the house was built in the 1860s, so it would've been as the craze was dying down. But here's something that can't be denied. There are still Spiritualists today, so we can't judge individuals based on general history.
Regardless of what the true history may be, it does seem that something was conjured in the home. Most of the corners were rounded in the mansion, but not all and it was in the one 90 degree angled corner that legend claims that George Stickney was found slumped over in with a horrified look on his face. Was it just a coincidence that he died in THE one corner that his beliefs would have led him to believe that an evil spirit could have been trapped? The listener who originally suggested this location to us was named Kelsey and she told us that as kids, they were told the house was built with no
corners, so that the Devil couldn't kill George Stickney. It would seem that the spirit of George is trapped in his former home. His full bodied apparition has been seen walking the halls. Roderick Smith claimed that he often heard strange noises in the house and his dogs were very restless there. They never seemed comfortable and would growl at unseen things. Smith said that he had heard that Satanists had lived in the house before him and that they tainted the house with their black magic rituals. The truth was that hippies had lived in the mansion doing drugs and spray painting graffiti on the walls. They painted the walls in dark colors and built fires right on the floors of the house. More than likely, they were just squatters rather than devil worshippers. Smith was convinced they had created the heavy atmosphere.
The strangest spirit reported at the house is that of a woman in a wedding dress who is usually seen peeking around a curtain in one of the upstairs rooms. No one knows who she is, so some wonder if this is a conjured spirit from so many years ago. She was allegedly caught in a picture when a real estate agent took pictures of the property in preparation of putting it on the market. Some doubt that there are any hauntings at the Stickney property.
The couple who moved in after Roderick Smith reported no strange happenings, but the police have had several experiences. Officer Ken Hoffman witnessed several drawers opening and closing on their own. In 2007, Officer Hoffman and Police Chief Norbert Sauers both saw a woman in white walk past a front window while they were talking to each other in an office. They went outside to see who the woman was and she had disappeared. Chief Sauers is a skeptic, but he can't deny that he has heard disembodied footsteps and pounding in the walls and seen lights turn on and off. Toilets have flushed on their own. Several officers have quit after experiencing activity in the house.
The Dole Mansion
Six miles away stands the Dole Mansion in, of all places, a town named Crystal Lake. The Dole Mansion was built in the Italianate style in 1865 for Grain Baron and Ice Harvester Charles Sidney Dole. Dole owned over 1000 acres of land and he created Lakeland Farms where he set up 12 commercial ice houses to harvest ice from the pristine waters of Crystal Lake. He named the company Crystal Ice Company. This turned Crystal Lake into a leading commercial center.
This site almost became an Amazon Distribution Center in 2021. Today, Pulte homes is building a neighborhood. But the mansion remains featuring an exterior made from locally made bricks, native stone, and dark walnut wood and oak. Dole built a backyard horse track and even put in railway tracks from the train station to his front door for his daughter's wedding. Although there are historians who claim they were used for the ice business. In 1922, Eliza Louise "Lou" Ringling, yes, of THAT Ringling family, and several other Chicago based investors, bought Lakeland Farms, which included the Dole Mansion. (Eliza was the widow of Al Ringling. They refurbished the mansion and added a large tutor style addition to the south of the mansion. They opened the mansion as Crystal Lake Country Club complete with a speakeasy since Prohibition was in effect. There were 44 rooms, two 18 hole golf courses and a large ballroom for lavish parties. Large swaths of Lakeland Farms was sold as plots for people to build homes near the lake. Things were great until the Great Depression hit and memberships dried up, so the country club closed its doors. In 1944, the Franciscan Order of Lake Forest purchased the property, so they could use it as a prep seminary named St. Mary Minor School for Boys. They unfortunately ripped out a lot of the good stuff like marble fireplaces and stained glass. The mansion itself became a Franciscan chapel. The seminary closed in 1969 and several years later, the First Congregational Church (FCC) purchased the property, renovated and opened “Lakeside Center,” which was a Community Center and housed the Friendship House Day Care Center for Children. The FCC had the longest run here, deciding to sell in 2002. And while much of the property is getting developed, the Lakeside Legacy Foundation was formed to save the mansion and today, the property is simply called The Dole. The community gathers here for farmer markets, festivals, art shows and live entertainment performances in Lou’s Lounge. Local artisans use the former bedrooms for studios.
The mansion has its spirits. Kevin Dalby, a former security and maintenance worker at the Dole, told Patch in 2012, "Once when I was on the garden level, I saw a dark shadow figure running from one side of the hall to the other late one afternoon. It wasn't a person...During one of the First Fridays, while we were getting ready, I thought I saw a Victorian woman in my peripheral vision. But then, she just disappeared." People believe this is the ghost of Lou Ringling. Some guests at the Dole thought they saw a young girl in a period dress running up the staircase.
Erin McElroy is an advancement coordinator for Lakeside Legacy and she said, "We definitely have had a lot of photographers come in here, take pictures in natural light and then claim their photograph prints have orbs on them...Myself, there are times when I've experienced drastic changes in temperatures, and times when I've been working here alone when I didn't feel like I was alone."
Joe Diamond had a studio here and claimed to be a mind reading mystic. He took pictures and claimed to capture abnormalities. In one of the photos that Diamond took of a staircase, there was a huge black shadow in front of the railing that Diamond couldn't explain.
Trudy82 wrote in 2009, "In 2006, I rented a teaching studio at the Dole Mansion - a historic site in Crystal Lake, Illinois that had been bought by a non-profit organization and is now called Lakeside Legacy Arts Park. It's a beautiful, sprawling mansion built in the 1800's with a very long and huge addition added on sometime in the early 1900's. The building was first a private residence for the Dole family, and then with the new addition it was used as many different things, including a country club and a seminary, and was then abandoned and scheduled for demolition until the arts foundation bought it. Now all kinds of artists and musicians use it as studio, gallery and performance space and it really is a magnificent place! Having such rich history, it naturally has some resident ghosts as well. People talk of a lady in white who appears in the upstairs window of the original mansion pulling aside the curtain and looking out the window at night. My friend's husband saw her one night as well. I wasn't expecting I'd actually have many experiences myself, but in fact I had quite a few during my year and a half renting a studio there! All of the studios are in the addition, which was mainly used as a seminary, although I have no idea what else it may have been in the past. When I first moved in I renovated the entire space, and at night I would often hear whisperings and laughing when no one was around. Luckily it didn't sound sinister, but more like people having friendly conversation. So once I got used to it, it wasn't scary. One night my friend (we'll call her Catherine) and I were the only two people left in the whole building. There were no cars in the parking lot and it was late at night. We were standing outside my studio door talking and getting ready to go home, when suddenly Catherine stopped talking and said, "Are you hearing that?" I listened to the conversation going on between two women down the hall (much clearer and physically present than the ones I heard coming from the walls at times) and I nonchalantly said, "Yeah..." Catherine said, "Aren't we the only ones here?" Realization dawned, and we both stared at each other with big eyes for a moment, and the conversation abruptly stopped in mid-sentence. We went down the hall to investigate, and the room we heard the voices coming from was empty. So was the entire hallway. We stood in silence staring into the room for a few moments, and suddenly I sensed a curious presence. I wasn't afraid because I didn't sense any maliciousness in it... Just curiosity. But then I felt as if it started walking toward us, and at that precise moment Catherine abruptly turned with a shudder and said, "C'mon, let's go!" She started power walking down the hallway, and I followed close behind, although I still don't think they had any negative intent. I had many little experiences there, including a very scary experience of being completely alone in the building late at night during a violent thunderstorm, listening to the typical whispering and laughing coming from the walls that I had gotten used to, when the building was hit by lightning! I literally thought a bomb had gone off! Then the VERY VERY loud and ancient fire alarm system started blasting like crazy in the hallway, and the burglar alarm started going off too. I think I just about peed my pants in that moment! I ran right home after that! The other occurrence that really stands out in my memory is one evening when I was teaching a voice student of mine and my stereo (which controls the sound for my digital piano) started flashing on and off and then one of the light bulbs from the ceiling fan exploded and shattered right over my student's head! THAT was quite an experience. My poor student was a bit shaken up after that. Most of the spirits that I've encountered in that building seem rather happy or just plain curious about all us artists being there. There is only one negative presence that I sense, and it stays in its territory over on the original mansion side. If you go up to the second story (the second and third floors of the mansion side are still waiting to be renovated and are closed to most visitors) there is a very ominous feeling room with a very huge old wooden armoire in it. The armoire is big enough for three or four people to stand inside of it. I got this really foreboding feeling the first time I saw that armoire, and when I walked inside it with a friend one time, I went back into the corner of it and heard screaming in my ears! I couldn't make out any words but I got the general feeling like they were screaming at me to get out. Naturally, I did very quickly!
kpklonghorn27 wrote in 2011, "All right, I am 13 so you probably won't believe me but, just keep reading. Living in Crystal Lake, I've been there quite a bit for Park district stuff or school art shows. I was a skeptic until my birthday two years ago. On a dare from my friend, I had to go all the way upstairs and wait for five minutes before I could come down. This changed my views on the paranormal forever. I was waiting out my five minuets and I heard foot steps and looked down the hallway and saw an apparition appear down the hallway. It went into the room all the way down the hall and to the right. It looked like a man and I think it might have been Mr. Dole."
Cherry Branch Guest House
Bill Murray played the cynical and egotistical television weatherman Phil Connors in the 1993 film Groundhog Day and one of the settings is the Cherry Tree Inn in Woodstock, Illinois. This location is owned by Lori Miarecki, who also owns the Cherry Branch Guest House just around the corner. The Cherry Branch got its start in 1910 as a boarding house. That makes this the oldest Victorian B&B in the city. It later became the Bundling Board Inn and now runs as a B&B with three guest suites that have private baths and the house features a fully stocked kitchen.
Lori bought the property in 2022 and it didn't take long for her to realize that there were some unseen guests in the house. The first indication was that the lights would turn on and off when she was working alone in the house. At first she figured it was an electrical problem. An electrician said that everything looked okay and he couldn't figure out why the lights were doing that. Lori didn't really want to believe it was ghosts, but then doors started to open and close on their own. She installed an eye-latch with a J-hook on a basement door to keep it closed. one day, the door started rattling like crazy and when she ran to see what was going on, she found the latch nearly falling out of the wall. So something was shaking that door pretty hard. What had she locked in or out? A friend of hers named Lincoln was helping make up the Petunia Room and the door to the room opened on him by itself. In stepped a shadow figure and the minute it realized it had been spotted, it jumped back out of the room and slammed the door shut. It was darker in the room and he thought perhaps it had been his wife, but he found her on the first floor cleaning the Chrysanthemum Room. The couple checked the house and found that they were the only people there.
Lori's daughter Megan lives in the third floor apartment and she has felt things in the house. Megan has witnessed objects flying across rooms, especially in the basement, so she refuses to go down there. Guests have also seen objects fly across rooms. Another guest saw a male figure seated in the easy chair in the unoccupied Chrysanthemum room. When they turned to get a better look, the man had vanished.
Lori isn't sure who exactly is haunting her inn, but she feels as though there must be two or three spirits. She thinks there is an older male, a child and something more negative in the basement. While she doesn't feel that last one is malevolent, it apparently likes to make a nuisance of itself by pounding on the doors or walls. She saw the older male sleeping on a loveseat, wearing a brown suit. She wondered who he was since all the guests had already checked out. She went inside and when she came back out, he was gone. She wonders if he goes back to the Robin Hill Convalescent Home, which was housed in the building from the 1940s to the 1960s.
The Count's House
The Count's House was built in 1860 in the town of McHenry, Illinois and many residents feel that it is a mysterious structure. The house was designed in the Greek Revival style and features a towering roofline, ornamental windows, large columns and carved vergeboards.
What really makes it unique is that it seems to have two faces. The north facade faces Waukegan (waa kee gan) Road and has a portico with full two-story Doric columns and the south facade faces Main Street and has two-story loggia with an upper balcony and several intricate moldings. Pretty much everything is original to the exterior of the house today, except for additions to its wing and the cedar shake shingles were replaced with asphalt shingles. The house has always been privately owned, so not open for tours. One of those owners was Count Oskar Bopp von Oberstadt, an Austrian count for whom the house is named. Over the years, people have reported numerous strange things around the house. There have been disembodied whispers heard in empty rooms, cold spots are felt, lights flicker in the windows and nobody feels alone in the house. A full=bodied female ghost wearing a period dress has been seen and the scent of roses is detected. Shadowy figures have also been seen.
Woodstock Town Square and James Dacey ghost
James Dacey had shot and killed Chicago Alderman Michael Gaynor in a saloon in 1884. This area was known as Chicago's Bloody Ninth Ward. Dacey didn't run and surrendered to police quickly. They didn't feel he could get a fair trial in Chicago, so the trial was moved to Woodstock.
The trial got national coverage and Dacey went with an insanity defense. The jury didn't buy it and found him guilty. The judge sentenced him to hang. Dacey's lawyers managed to get him a stay of execution while the case was reviewed, but a higher court upheld the decision. Dacey's brother and lawyers tried to get him judged insane and the Governor decided to grant a stay to have Dacey's sanity verified. There was another trial and several doctors testified and the jury ruled he was sane. Now we don't know if he was really upset about his coming execution or if he was mentally ill, but newspaper accounts claimed Dacey would sit in his cell and "howl in the most dismal tones." When guards came by his cell he would yell, shriek and shake his prison bars and if they got close enough to him, he would bite them as he foamed at the mouth. The day before his hanging, Dacey tried to kill himself with a pair of rusty shears. He then choked a priest and tried to beat guards with a broken bed post. They had to spray him with a water hose for 20 minutes to subdue him. He was shackled to his bed. A gallows was set up in Woodstock Square and a large crowd turned out to watch the hanging. A fence blocked the view from the public, so people had to buy tickets to watch. Dacey was led to the gallows and a white cap was placed over his face. He calmly accepted his fate and said that it was his happiest day since before his trial. His brain was sent for study with nothing unusual found. Dacey is at unrest and still haunts the courthouse on the square and the cell where he had been kept. His apparition is sometimes seen in the square as well.
Bull Valley Monster
And finally, we have the Bull Valley Monster. This cryptid seems to present itself in a variety of ways. We saw descriptions that likened it to a Bigfoot-like creature. Several Reddits made it sound like a human that had some kind of deformity and was a crazed killer. People claim it throws rocks at cars and there is even a Bull Valley Monster Hill Challenge run every year. It would be fun if it entailed people actually having to run from the entity. A man named Mike shared on Facebook, "When I was growing up I was told that a young couple went out there to make out, but got a flat tire so the young man parked under a tree cause it was raining out and told his girlfriend to stay in the car till he changed the tire, but it was taking along time and she kept hearing something rubbing the top of the car and when she went to find out what was taking so long she found him hanging from the tree and it was his arms swinging back and forth on the rooftop! And was told that The Bull Valley Monster killed him!"
McHenry County has some great historical sites to check out and American Ghost Walks offers ghost tours in some of the cities. Is that because these various locations are haunted? That is for you to decide!
We do want to point out that there are stories about the Woodstock Opera House being haunted by a ghost named Elvira, but everything we researched on that clearly revealed this was a newspaper hoax, so we didn't bother to include it. The building is gorgeous however.
No comments:
Post a Comment