HGB Ep. 598 - Brown Palace Hotel

Moment in Oddity - Diesel the Donkey (Suggested by: Chelsea Flowers)

There have been many instances in nature where one species of animal is orphaned and raised by another species. However, that type of situation can be a bit more rare when it comes to animals that live in a herd or flock. In the spring of 2024, a bow-hunter named Max Fennell was out in the wilderness when he came upon an unexpected sight that he captured on film. He spotted a herd of at least twelve Roosevelt elk on a hillside. That was not the least bit unusual for the area, however what was strange was that one of the members of the herd looked a bit different. This unique fellow was actually a donkey named Diesel. Five years prior to Fennell's discovery, the Drewry family had been out camping with their pet donkey near Clear Lake, California. Diesel had spooked and ran away. The distraught family searched for their friend, but despite seeing hoofprints and trail camera footage of their four legged family member, they were unable to locate him. The Drewry's were overjoyed at seeing Diesel thriving with his adoptive family despite missing having him at home. They decided to leave him be, to live his best life as an elk. We like to watch different species of animals living in peaceful coexistence, but a donkey living with a herd of elk, certainly is odd. 

This Month in History - Storming of the Bastille

In the month of July, on the 14th, in 1789, Parisian revolutionaries and mutinous troops stormed the Bastille. The Bastille was a royal fortress and prison in Paris, France. The populace were agitated over economic hardships and were frustrated with the monarchy. Fears that King Louis XVI was about to arrest France's newly constituted National Assembly led to the uprising. A mob approached the Bastille with demands for arms and ammunition. The guards resisted and the revolutionaries attacked, seizing the fortress which represented the monarchy's oppressive power. Approximately 100 of the revolutionaries lost their lives as well as governor Bernard-Rene de Launay and some of the guards. It was a fierce battle. The event was a culmination of many years of discontent by the people and is considered the starting point of the French Revolution. It began a decade of radical social and political change signalling the end of the old regime. Bastille Day is now a national holiday in France, commemorating the anniversary of the fall of the Bastille. 

Brown Palace Hotel (Suggested twice by Tim Kemble, Vicki Luther and David Law)

The Brown Palace Hotel and Spa is an iconic landmark in Downtown Denver. The hotel has stood for over 130 years and was one of the first atrium-style hotels ever built and was fire-proof. She was affectionately nicknamed The Grand Dame of Denver and she has stood as a sentinel in the downtown area, watching over the history that has unfolded here. The Brown hosted celebrities, Molly Brown, several Presidents and even the Beatles. And rumors claim that she hosts spirits as well. Several of them. Join us for the history and hauntings of the Brown Palace Hotel.

Let's set the stage. This is an excerpt from a September 1956 House and Garden article by Lucius Beebe: "Above and beyond its celebrity as one of the great hotels of the nation, the Brown possesses an even greater asset than culinary citations and the presence on its register of the names of the mighty and affluent. This is its sense of continuity, of being inseparably joined to the past. The Brown is from the old times, the good times, when all the country was young and there were those still living who could remember the Long Hunters and the Mountain Men. Over the shoulders of the young men in Brooks suits and sport jackets at the Ship Tavern, there are shadowy figures in fringed buckskin and raccoon hats with scalp knives at their belts drinking amazing quantities of Taos Lightning and planning ghostly wagon trains that shall set out from Kansas over the Jornada del Muerto, the Route of Death, for Santa Fe. Only the true believers, heirs to the second sight of the Medicine Men, can see them. But they are there." I grew up in the suburbs of Denver and also lived in the heart of Capitol Hill for a few years, so I'm very familiar with the idea that while Denver is a very modern city, it still embraces its Old West history. 

Denver can thank gold for its beginning. A prospector named William Russell lead a bunch of miners north of the Santa Fe Trail into what was then Kansas Territory at the confluence of the Cherry Creek and South Platte Rivers. They found gold there in 1858 and created a permanent settlement they called Auraria. The Colorado Gold Rush was off and running and brought another man who had been a general in the Pennsylvania state militia named William Larimer, Jr. He built Denver City across the river from Auraria. The name Denver came from Kansas territorial Governor James Denver. The two towns would merge as Denver before the Civil War.  

What would become Capitol Hill was originally owned by Henry C. Brown. Brown was born in 1820 in Ohio and his early work was in carpentry in St. Louis. He made a small fortune in California working as a master builder and he opened a sawmill. In 1858, he decided to relocate back to St. Louis and then he heard very promising things about a city named Decatur that was located in Nebraska. Brown sunk most of his money into the town, which went bust, so he went back to Missouri to make money in carpentry again. When he had $2,500 in his pocket, he decided to head to California again, but by the time he and his wife arrived in Denver, she was done with traveling and demanded that they stop. Brown set up a carpentry shop , but eventually decided to real estate was where the real money was at he bought and homesteaded the land that would become Capitol Hill and it was known as Brown's Bluff. It was given that name because people thought of it as a wasteland. Brown had hopes of building neighborhoods and he platted out the land, but settlers soon abandoned the future Mile High City for Cheyenne. Brown continued to believe in his plan.

Brown was right. Denver would be chosen to build the state capitol and Brown's Bluff was the perfect hill for placement. Brown donated the land for the Capitol building and he gave money so that a library could be founded. Soon Denver would be a booming metropolis. There was a triangular block of land bordered by Broadway, 17th Street and Tremont Place, in what would become downtown Denver, that Brown owned and he sold it to some English investors who planned to build a hotel on the plot. People were flocking to the West and Denver was a great stop over point, so places for people to stay were desperately needed. They dug out the foundation and went bankrupt, abandoning the project and leaving behind a hole that was used as a swimming pool by kids. Brown foreclosed on the land and took it back, deciding to build his own hotel there and he did just that, calling it the Brown Palace Hotel. He didn't have an ego or anything. And as we said, the plot was triangular, so the hotel is indeed, triangular.

Henry Brown hired Civil War veteran architect Frank E. Edbrooke to design the hotel and Edbrooke decided on the Italian Renaissance and Romanesque Revival styles. That design took nearly two tons of paper for the drawings and every guest room would face the streets. The hotel was built with an iron and steel frame constructed by Whitehouse & Wirgler Stone Company. Construction began in 1888 and red granite from Colorado and sandstone from Arizona were chosen for the building's exterior. Artist James Whitehouse was commissioned to create twenty-six medallions depicting Colorado animals. These were carved into the stone between the seventh-floor windows. When finished, the hotel stood taller than most everything around it, offering great views, morning and afternoon sun depending on which side of the hotel you were on and the hotel really appeared like a giant ship with a massive prow.

Edbrooke designed an amazing interior as well. There was an atrium lobby with balconies rising eight floors and those balconies had cast iron railings with ornate grillwork panels. The atrium was topped with stained-glass windows. The wall of the lobby were paneled with onyx brought in from an onyx mine in Torreon, Mexico. The Grand Salon, which is known as the Onyx Room now, and the 8th floor ballroom were also paneled in the onyx. There was also an 8th floor dining room that could seat 250 guests and offered panoramic views of 300 miles of the Rocky Mountains. The room was two stories and the windows had stained glass fruit designs at the tops of the windows. The floor also had six private dining rooms and the kitchen was up there as well. Floors and partition walls were built of hollow blocks of porous terra cotta fire-proofing, making this one of the first fireproof structures in America. Each room had its own fireplace. There was steam heat, a huge engine room, a power plant within the hotel, and an ice machine that could make five tons of ice a day. An artesian well provided the hotel with its own water. The interior was furnished at a cost of $400,000, which included fine china and silver, Irish linen, sofas covered in silk, and furniture made from white mahogany, cherry and antique oak. The entire hotel cost $1.6 million to build.

The hotel opened on August 12, 1892 with 400 guest rooms that rented for between $3 and $5 a night under the co-management of William Bush and Maxey Tabor. Bush built and managed the Broadway theater across from the hotel and he had vast experience in managing hotels. Maxey was the son of Augusta and Horace Tabor and learned the hotel business from his dad. It was Tabor's expensive taste that led to the expensive furnishing of the Brown. The hotel also featured eighteen unique storefronts. The first guests to use the dining room were the Triennial Conclave of Knights Templar and they had a 7-course dinner with a wine list of 227 different items that included 28 different champagnes. Brown's wife died in February of 1893 and he moved out of the Sherman Street Mansion that they shared and took up residence at the Brown Palace. The crash of 1893 hit him hard and he wasn't able to pay his bills. This left the managers of the hotel thinking that they were actually going to have to evict him. Brown was saved from that when a fellow carpenter who hit it big in the Cripple Creek gold rush, W.S. Stratton, bought the Brown Palace and he let Brown stay there. In 1894, Brown set his sights on marrying a 22-year-old grocery clerk. He was 74. Surprisingly, the marriage didn't last and they were divorced by 1900. Brown went to San Diego, California and he died there in 1906. His body was brought back to Denver and laid in state in the Capitol. After his death, there was litigation with Brown's son over the deed and the Stratton estate officially bought the hotel in 1907.

Horace Bennett and Associates bought the hotel in 1922. One of those associates was Charles Boettcher and he and his brother Claude bought the hotel when the Depression forced Bennett to sell some of his holdings. Claude guided the hotel through the Depression and two World Wars. In 1937, two murals were added to the hotel lobby by artist Allen Tupper True named "Stage Coach" and "Airplane Travel." When prohibition ended, the Ship Tavern was added to the hotel. In 1959, the Denver Broncos were born in the lobby of the Brown Palace. Lamar Hunt was starting a new football league called the American Football League and Bob Howsam agreed to meet him at the hotel to finalize a plan for Howsam to own the Denver franchise. The AFL and NFL would eventually merge into the game of football we know today. Also in 1959 came an expansion to add more rooms and this was in the form of a 22-story annex across Tremont Place that offered 231 rooms. Eventually this annex became a Comfort Inn and today are a Holiday Inn Express. The Boettcher name was associated with the Brown Palace for fifty years and then it was sold to Associated Inns and Restaurants Company of America in 1980. Rank Hotels of North America took over management in 1983.

Guests who came to the Grand Dame of Denver were Frontier and Alaska gangster Jefferson “Soapy” Smith, Louise Sneed Hill, Margaret “Molly” Brown, Andrew Carnegie, Thomas Edison, Peter Lorre, Jane Russell, Red Skelton and Charles Lindbergh. The first president to visit was Teddy Roosevelt in 1905. Incidentally, only three presidents that have served after Teddy have not visited the hotel. Every other President has been a guest. The Beatles were coming to Colorado to perform at Red Rocks Ampitheater, which is THE best placed to see a concert, period. Fight me. That's why so many groups have released live albums that were recorded at Red Rocks. Anyway, when the Beatles arrived at the Brown Palace on August 26, 1964, pandemonium ensued. There is fun story about a character who stayed here named Lord Ogilivie shared in Corinne Hunt's 1982 book "The Brown Palace Story." (Pg. 45)

Interesting guests would show up in the lobby during the National Western Stock Show every year: the champion bulls. Crow Holdings acquired the Brown in 2014 and today it is owned by Crescent Real Estate LLC and is managed by Marriott. Today, the Brown is officially known as The Brown Palace Hotel and Spa, Autograph Collection and features not only the spa, but afternoon tea, the Molly Brown Suite Experience, the Eisenhower Suite, a French restaurant, live jazz in the atrium lobby and honey bees that produce honey for spa products and fresh jars of honey. There are tours offered that include ghost tours and the hotel is rumored to be haunted by several spirits. 

Let's talk about one reason we might have a haunting going on here. Murder. The Brown Palace had a bar called the Marble Bar in 1911 and it was the scene of a double murder and as is the case with many murders, this was all over a woman and jealousy. First, we'll introduce our characters. There was Sylvester Von Phul who everybody called Tony. He was a big athletic guy measuring over six feet and weighing 220 pounds. His features were handsome and he easily caught the ladies' eyes with his deep set blue eyes and pompadour hair. Tony was 34-years-old in 1911. There was Frank Henwood who had only been in Denver a short time. He was a friend and business associate of a man named John Springer. Frank was an impeccable dresser and thin and had traveled the world. He was divorced with two daughters and 35-years-old in 1911. Isabel Patterson Springer was born in Kansas in 1886 and was a social butterfly who worked her way up to elite socialite. She was married to a traveling shoe salesman and divorced him in 1907. Only a few weeks after that divorce, Isabel married Colorado businessman John Springer, who was very powerful and very rich. He was forty-seven and she was twenty-seven, so she made the perfect trophy wife. And she fit the bill being both beautiful and vivacious. Isabel loved to throw parties, especially at the Brown Palace, and everybody was always eager for an invite.

Isabel was young and unsatisfied in her marriage to Springer who was often away on business, so she took up with both Tony Von Phul and Frank Henwood. She had met von Phul on a trip to St. Louis and after she left, she started writing him some very steamy letters. The two met up in Hot Springs, Arkansas where Isabel went to recover from a surgery and the two were seen doing the party circuit together. Isabel had met Frank at her husband's office and the three all started hanging out as friends. Things crossed the line at some point and Frank would visit Isabel at her and John's 12,000 acre ranch outside of Denver when John would be out of town. Isabel couldn't decide between the two men. At what point they found out about each other, we don't know but apparently von Phul started threatening Isabel that he would start sending her letters to him, to her husband one at a time, unless she dropped her husband and Frank for him. Isabel turned to Frank for help in getting back "some foolish little letters." Frank agreed. He wasn't about to let von Phul blackmail Isabel.

The Springers had a suite at the Brown Palace and Isabel and Frank met there. This was easy to do because frank also had a room at the Brown, Room 715. Isabel again asked for Frank to get moving on getting the letters back. He told her that he wanted her to write a note to von Phul telling him that things were over, but she refused. Frank persisted and a letter was indeed typed up. Isabel had summoned von Phul to come from St. Louis and when he arrived, he checked into the Brown Palace and was given Room 524. he asked later to be moved to Room 603 next to the Springer's suite. When he checked in, he was given the Dear John letter, which told him it was over and that Isabel was sending someone to have a final talk with him.

Henwood made an appointment with von Phul to meet that evening, May 23rd, 1911 at 5:30 in the afternoon. Before that meeting happened, Frank found out that von Phul and left to meet up with Isabel and her mother at a department store. Frank met up with him at the store and encouraged him not to make a scene and got him to get into a car with him to go back to the Brown and things got very heated in the car and Frank joined von Phul in his room at the Brown. Henwood insisted that Tony return the letters to Isabel and von Phul punched him in the face. Then von Phul hit Frank with a shoe tree and he pulled a revolver from his pocket and threatened to kill Frank. Frank left the room. Isabel later told Frank that von Phul  had punched her and that he had done it twice more in the past. She also said that von Phul said he was going to kill her husband John. So Frank Henwood got a gun. 

The next evening, May 24th, Frank and von Phul met up at the Marble Bar in the Brown Palace. Von Phul asked a friend to change places with him so he could be near Frank because he had already licked him twice and might want to do it again. Frank would claim that von Phul said to him about John Springer, "I'll go upstairs and drag the gray-headed expletive out and show him who is the master here." Frank got in his face, and von Phul knocked him down and then reached in his pocket. Frank thought he was grabbing a gun and he pulled his gun and fired at von Phul. He not only hit von Phul twice, but he shot two other men. The bartender was hit in the leg and an innocent bystander named George Copeland was fatally wounded. Tony died of his wounds the next day.  

Frank wasn't tried for the murder of von Phul, but rather the unintentional killing of Copeland. This was done so that Frank couldn't claim self-defense in killing von Phul which would have made Copeland's death just negligence. The prosecution really wanted Frank to be convicted, so they thought this was best and it worked. Henwood was found guilty of first degree murder and sentenced to death, but this was commuted to a life sentence by the state pardon board. Then in May 1922, Isabel's husband John made a personal appeal to the Colorado governor to pardon Henwood and he agreed to do it. So Henwood was released from prison the prison in Canon City as long as he promised to never return to Denver. John Springer divorced Isabel and said she could keep his last name, but he forbade her to ever return to Denver. She moved to the East Coast to try becoming a model, but got addicted to opium and overdosed in 1917 at the age of 31.

Employees and guests claim to hear a ghostly orchestra on occasion and the full-bodied apparition of a waiter in a period uniform has been seen near the service elevator. A ticket salesman in an old uniform is seen walking around in the lobby. The sounds of children playing and the crying of babies is heard when there are no children around. Lights turn themselves off and on. A spirit wearing what looks like train conductor clothes from another time has been seen near the entrance and if he is approached, he floats down to the ground floor and disappears. Incidentally, we have mentioned in other episodes that there are tunnels that run under ground in Denver and some of these tunnels are reputedly under the Brown palace.

Night watchmen claim to see Henry Brown's ghost in the wee hours of the morning pacing the hallways. The spirit is seen walking through the walls  of the Churchill Cigar Bar in the hotel. The main dining room was once known as the San Marco Room and there was always live music. One of the main musical groups that played here were the San Marco Strings. An employee was working one night when he heard muic coming from the dining room and he was confused because it was closed. When he looked inside, he saw a formally dressed string quartet playing. He went inside and approached the group and told them, "You're not supposed to be in here." One of the men calmly replied, "Oh, don't worry about us. We live here." The musicians then disappeared.

Room 401 houses the spirit of an unfriendly male. Women are often touched by something unseen when in the closet of this room. A former owner's wife was named Edna and she is blamed for lights turning off and on by themselves. She also may be the elderly female spirit that wears a long black dress and complains that the heat isn't working in her room and then vanishes when the maintenance guy comes to fix things. A bellhop from a time gone by likes to swipe newspapers from doorways. He is also seen walking through walls. Rooms were never rented by the hour, but a ghost of a lady of the evening has been seen. She may wander over from buildings across the street because there had once been a gambling hall and brothel over there that patrons of the Brown Palace could get to via a tunnel going under the street. 

Louise Crawford Hill lived in Room 904 for thirteen years from 1942 to 1955. Louise was born in North Carolina in 1862 and she arrived in Denver in 1893. She was determined to climb her way to the top of society and she accomplished this by marrying the very rich Crawford Hill whose father had been a smelter magnate. Louise created the first social register in Denver and called it "Who's Who in Denver Society." Louise wouldn't include Maggie Brown (Molly) on her list, so Maggie dubbed her "the snobbiest woman in Denver." Crawford died in 1922 and Louise continued to live in their mansion until 1942 when she sold it because she couldn't find any hired help to upkeep it because of World War II. She was mostly a recluse at the hotel and she died there in 1955. Jenna Robbins has given haunted tours of the haunted areas of the hotel for years. She told the Denver Post in 2016, "I was a I-don’t-believe-in-ghosts person, but all it took was an experience I can’t explain in any other way than ‘ghosts must exist’ to change my mind." The paper Westword reported in 2008 what that experience was, "Years later, when Mrs. Hill was but a distant memory, renovations were being done to the top two floors of the hotel — where she had lived — and a hotel historian [Robbins] was giving tours of the floors, telling interested participants about the people who used to reside there. When she got to the tales of Mrs. Hill, which involved heartbreak suffered over a lost love, the hotel’s main switchboard suddenly began receiving calls from Room 904 — which had been stripped of all furniture, lights, wallpaper, carpet and telephones during the renovation. Hotel operators could hear only static when they answered the calls. And when the historian removed Mrs. Hill’s saga from the tour, the phone calls from Room 904 ceased."

A Haunting in Colorado, founded by Alexis Rae, did an investigation at the hotel in 2021 and got "Let go" to come through on a Spirit Box. Alexis said that some activity that entailed an unseen spirit pulling the covers off of people, seemed to start when the hotel started offering ghost tours. She asked the spirits if this bothered them and very clearly through the box came the answer, "It does." Later, a male voice yelled "foot!" There was an "okay" and Alexis asked if they wanted to conversate for a little bit and there was a clear "yes" and then an "excuse me." Another spirit said "Leave me alone."  

The Brown Palace is a modern day reminder of the Old West. The hotel is both elegant and historic with a past rich enough to lend itself to ghost stories. Is the Brown Palace Hotel haunted? That is for you to decide! 

HGB Ep. 597 - Frederic Remington Museum of Art

Moment in Oddity - Japanese Spider Crabs

Although Diane and I love all critters, we also eat them and one mention of crab makes our mouths start to water. We do not have the opportunity to enjoy crab often, but there is a species of crab where just one single crab could feed us for several meals. This is the Japanese spider crab which is found off the waters of Japan in depths of 50 to 300 meters. The species only moves to shallower waters during the breeding season. They are scavengers by nature and can live between 50 and 100 years. These crabs are known as decorator crabs. They attach various sponges, algae and other items to their bodies to aid in their camouflage to help avoid predation. The Japanese spider crab is a slow moving creature however, happening upon one of these crabs could also elicit nightmares. The tasty delicacy has a carapace that can be up to 16 inches across and their leg spanse can measure up to 12.5 feet, making the Japanese spider crab the largest arthropod on earth and their size certainly makes them odd. 

This Month in History - Transit Visas Issued to Jews (Suggested by: Duey Oxberger)

In the month of July in 1940, Japanese diplomat Chiune Sugihara (shee-oo-nee Soo-gee-haa-ruh) issued transit visas to Jewish refugees. Sugihara was stationed in Lithuania to gather intelligence on German and Soviet troop movements. He witnessed Jewish families seeking escape from Nazi-occupied Europe and began writing visas for Jewish people to travel to Japan in order to seek further refuge in other countries. Sugihara was ordered by his superiors to not issue the visas, but he later stated, "I may have disobeyed my government but if I didn't I would be disobeying God". With his wife's support, Sugihara spent long hours issuing over 2,000 visas. Some articles credit him with saving 6,000 Jewish lives. Some of the visas, however, were never used and recent research has revealed that the actual number of rescues cannot be substantiated. On occasion, single visas were used for entire households as well. In addition to the travel visas, Tokyo required travelers to have a final destination permit to be allowed to travel through Japan. Dutch consul Jan Zwartendijk (Yawn Svart-en-dick) who was also stationed in Lithuania at the time, stamped thousands of Jewish passports to visa-free Dutch Curacao. The fees for the refugees' transit across the Soviet Union was paid for by various Jewish organizations. Once the refugees arrived in Japan, they left for the United States, Australia, Canada and other countries. Some were later imprisoned in Japanese controlled Shanghai until the end of the war.

Frederic Remington Museum of Art 

Frederic Remington created some of the most iconic Western art in the history of America. His art was able to bring the untamed frontier to the big city and today is evocative of the Wild West. Remington not only drew and painted the West, he lived it as well and he loved playing the role of pseudo cowboy. His art is showcased at the Frederic Remington Museum of Art in Ogdensburg, New York, a town where he grew up and would spend time in his adulthood. Even though Remington didn't live in the house that became the museum, it is said he haunts the place. And there is a legend connected to the house that also seems to have left behind a ghost story. Join us for the history and hauntings of the Frederic Remington Museum of Art.  

Ogdensburg is located on the southern shore of the St. Lawrence River in New York. The Iroquoian were some of the first indigenous people here and they were followed by the Five Nations of the Haudenosaunee, which were the Mohawk, Onondaga, Oneida, Cayuga and Seneca. The French were the first European settlers to establish a presence and they built a mission named Fort de La Presentation in 1749. They named the colony New France. Parts of the French and Indian War would take place nearby and after the British won, France ceded its land east of the Mississippi to Britain. The British renamed the fort to Fort Oswegatchie after their Native allies. These allies would be driven out of the area after Britain lost the Revolutionary War by American settlers and they renamed the village Ogdensburg after a landowner named Samuel Ogden in 1796. The village was incorporated in 1817 and became the City of Ogdensburg in 1868. The house that would become the Frederic Remington Museum of Art was built here in 1810 and Remington would begin living in Ogdensburg in 1872.

We should probably talk about Frederic Remington before we share about the museum created in his honor. First a little fun fact, yes, he was related to Eliphalet Remington who had founded the oldest gunmaker in America, the Remington Arms Company, which made the Remington Repeater Rifle. And he was related to famous mountain man Jedediah Smith. Frederic was born in New York in 1861 to Union Army Colonel Seth Remington who was off fighting in the Civil War for the first four year's of Frederic's life. Before serving in the military, Seth had been a newspaper editor and postmaster, so after the war, he moved the family to Bloomington, Illinois because he was appointed editor of the Bloomington Republican. In 1867, the Remingtons moved back to New York. 

Seth had dreams of his son going to West point, but that was never going to happen. Frederic wasn't a good student and being that he was the creative type, he wasn't good at math. He loved the outdoors and was an excellent hunter and swimmer and he was a good horseman. Frederic was also a very talented artist. He started sketching soldiers and cowboys when he was still quite young. His father moved the family to Ogdensburg when he was eleven, so that he could attend the Vermont Episcopal Institute, which was a military school. Rather than push Frederic into a military future, Frederic got the opportunity to have a drawing lesson and he was hooked. Transferring to another military school didn't do anything either to foster a desire for a military life. Frederic spent most of his time drawing caricatures of his classmates. He wrote his uncle, "I never intend to do any great amount of labor. I have but one short life and do not aspire to wealth or fame in a degree which could only be obtained by an extraordinary effort on my part."

So, art it was and Frederic went off to study art at Yale University. While there, he found the style that he would pursue. He loved action and drew men boxing and playing sports. Still life bored him and he wasn't into classical art at all. His first published illustration was a cartoon of a "bandaged football player" and it ran in Yale's school paper, the Yale Courant. While Frederic was at school, his father contracted tuberculosis. As it got worse, Frederic decided to leave Yale and he did that in 1879. His father died the following year. He was only fifty. For a time after that, Remington drifted in life. He meandered through various jobs and proposed to a girlfriend, but her father rejected the offer. Frederic took his inheritance and headed for Montana with the intention of setting up a mining interest and when he didn't have enough money for that, he thought about setting up a cattle operation. He still didn't have the capital for that. But something that would prove to be wonderful for the world of art happened. Remington sat and marinated in the West. He got to see the bison roaming the prairie. He observed the Native Americans of the Plains. He witnessed confrontations between those tribes and the US Cavalry. There were the cowboys and the miners and the horses and unfenced cattle. Remington was getting an authentic taste of the American West of the 1880s. And he was going to share it with the world. 

Remington's first commercially published piece was in Harper's Weekly. The money wasn't rolling in though, so Frederic decided to try sheep ranching in Kansas. That proved to be boring, so he sold the land that he had sunk his inheritance into and he returned to New York to get some money from his mother, only to return to Kansas and lose money on a hardware business. Then he tried being a partner in a saloon. In 1884, he went back to New York to fetch that young woman whom he had wanted to marry earlier. Her father was willing to let her marry Remington now, even though he seemed to be rudderless. So Remington made Eva Caten his wife and brought her back to Kansas. She wasn't thrilled with the saloon business. When Remington showed her his collection of sketches and revealed that drawing was his real interest, she packed her bags and headed back to Ogdensburg. This caused Remington to get more serious about his art and he started selling paintings. He realized that he really could make money doing this and he headed back to New York to reunite with Eva and he went to the Art Students League of New York to refine his skills. Western themes were becoming really popular, so everything was about to sync perfectly for Remington. He was 25 and it was 1886 when Harper's Weekly gave him his first full-color front page. The magazine would send him on various assignments through the years.

In his first year of being a commercial artist, Remington made $1,200 and he told a friend, "That's a pretty good break for an ex cow-puncher to come to New York with $30 and catch on it 'art'." Remington used various mediums in his work and he tried to get the most accurate colors he could to depict what the West really looked like. In 1887, Remington met a man who would become a good friend of his, Theodore Roosevelt. Roosevelt had just finished writing his book "Ranch Life and the Hunting Trail" and it was going to be serialized in The Century Magazine and he needed over eighty illustrations to accompany it, so he commissioned this young, new artist named Remington. Roosevelt himself was only 29 at the time. The two men became fast friends as they realized that they both loved adventure and the West. The two would remain lifelong friends. As his skill grew, Remington was able to take on more complex works and in 1889 he won a second-class medal at the Paris Exposition. The following year, he held a one-man show and it was at this time that he really put forward a public persona of being a cowboy and spoke like a cowboy and changed up his biography, throwing in a few myths of his escapades in the frontier. Harper's Weekly had him under a handshake agreement and they really embraced the pseudo-cowboy thing, launching a promotional campaign to that effect. 

In his personal life, Remington and his wife relocated to New Rochelle, New York, which would put them closer to New York City in 1890. It was the perfect spot because Remington could still enjoy open spaces and horseback riding, while still having the big city to facilitate his art with publishing houses and galleries. Remington tried to stay active because his success had led to indulgences that added quite a bit of girth to his frame and he would struggle with it for the rest of his life. The house was located at 301 Webster Avenue on a hill known as Lathers Woods, named for Colonel Richard Lathers. Lathers built a few houses on his 300 acre estate as investments. One of these was bought by Remington. The house was designed in the Gothic revival style by architect Alexander Jackson Davis, with great views of the countryside and Long Island Sound. Remington called the estate Endion which was an Ojibwa word meaning "the place where I live." The house had everything the couple needed or wanted except a studio for Frederic. He used the large attic for a while, but eventually retained New Rochelle architect O. William Degen in 1896 to plan a studio addition to the house. Remington would describe the studio to a friend as being "Czar-sized." In this studio, he would create most of his life's work, which included over 3,000 pieces. The studio was filled with items he had collected and he would dress models in genuine pieces for inspiration. The studio has been recreated at the Buffalo Bill Center of the West in Cody, Wyoming.

One of the famous moments in Western history that Remington documented in January of 1891, albeit after-the-fact, was the Massacre at Wounded Knee. He went through the tents of the wounded soldiers and got their stories. They had all thought that this was going to be an easy surrender of Big Foot and his warriors, but Big Foot's group fought back by concealing guns under blankets that they threw off when the 7th Cavalry arrived. An interesting paranormal tangent to this is that the medicine man of the tribe had given the warriors ghost shirts and told them that no bullet would be able to wound them if they wore the shirts. And the warriors believed him. Obviously, that wasn't true and Remington wrote, "Lying on his back, with a bullet through the body, Lieutenant Mann grew stern when he got to the critical point in his story. 'I saw three or four young bucks drop their blankets, and I saw that they were armed. ‘Be ready to fire, men; there is trouble.' There was an instant, and then we heard sounds of firing in the center of the Indians. ‘Fire!’ I shouted, and we poured it into them. Oh yes, Mann, but the trouble began when the old medicine-man threw the dust in the air. That is the old Indian signal of ‘defiance,’ and no sooner had he done that act than those bucks stripped and went into action.  Just before that some one told me that if we didn’t stop that old man’s talk he would make trouble. He said that the white men’s bullets would not go through the ghost shirts. Said another officer, 'The way those Sioux worked those Winchesters was beautiful.' Which criticism, you can see, was professional. Added another, 'One man was hit early in the firing, but he continued to pump his Winchester; but growing weaker and weaker, and sinking down gradually, his shots went higher and higher, until his last went straight up in the air. Those Indians were plumb crazy. Now, for instance, did you notice that before they fired they raised their arms to heaven? That was devotional. Yes, captain, but they got over their devotional mood after the shooting was over,' remonstrated a cynic. 'When I passed over the field after the fight one young warrior who was near to his death asked me to take him over to the medicine-man’s side, that he might die with his knife in the old conjurer’s heart. He had seen that the medicine was bad, and his faith in the ghost shirt had vanished. There was no doubt but that every buck there thought that no bullet could touch him.”

Remington would be referred to as "The Soldier Artist" because of his extensive work with featuring soldiers and cavalrymen and their stories in his work. Frederic spent much of the 1890s traveling through Mexico and the US. He eventually made it to Florida where he discovered Florida Crackers, which were our version of cowboys. Remington wrote of his work, "My drawing is done entirely from memory. I never use a camera now. The interesting never occurs in nature as a whole, but in pieces. It's more what I leave out than what I add." Frederic definitely focused on the outside world of the West. Saloons and dance halls didn't really make it into his work and he rarely depicted women. Most of the females he drew were Native American. In 1895, Remington started working on sculpting. He asked his friend, Sculptor Frederick Ruckstull to teach him how to sculpt and his first armature and clay model featured a cowboy fighting to stay aboard a rearing, bucking bronco, with a stirrup swinging free, a quirt in one hand and a fistful of mane and reins in the other. He entitled it The Bronco Buster and it would be his most popular sculpture. He made $6,000 over three years on the piece.

Remington spent seven days a week in his studio, but he was becoming bored as 1900 rolled around and he longed for a war to get started, so he could be a heroic war correspondent. Frederic lived in this kind of illusionary world where war would be good because as he told a friend he had "done nothing but potboil of late." Frederic had done a self-portrait of himself as a lean cowboy on horseback, but he was far from that and it would prove his undoing. He weighed in at nearly 300 pounds. That year, he bought an island on the U.S. side of the St. Lawrence River that he could use as a summer residence and place to live Crusoe-like, although it had a substantial cottage and outbuildings. He called it "Ingleneuk" and said of it that it was "the finest place on earth." Remington also took to writing novels, but that wasn't as successful, so he focused mostly on sculpture and painting. In 1908, he decided to sell the house in new Rochelle and before he did that, he built a bonfire in the front yard and burned dozens of his oil paintings that had been used for magazine illustration. Apparently, he did this as a statement that he was done with illustration for good. 

At the beginning of 1909, the Remingtons bought 45 acres in Ridgefield, Connecticut and they built a home and studio there. Although the house still stands today and is a National Historic Landmark known as the Frederic Remington House, Frederic didn't live in it for very long. In December of 1909, Remington had to have an emergency appendectomy and his extreme obesity led to complications and peritonitis and he died on December 26, 1909. Eva would survive him by nine years. The house where the Remington Museum is located was built in 1810 and as we said in the intro, Frederic never lived here. He probably was in the house though  as his friend George Hall had owned the house. Frederic's wife Eva was definitely in the house. She lived there with her sister Emma as guests of Hall from 1915 to 1918, when Eva passed away. Most of the items in the museum came from Eva Remington's 1918 estate. These items include scrapbooks, photographs, Remington's library, his easel, his paintbrushes, his hockey stick, his elk's tooth cufflinks and even the cigars that were in his pocket before he died. The Museum opened in 1923 as the Remington Art Memorial. That name changed to its current name as the Frederic Remington Art Museum in 1981. 

There are claims that the museum is haunted and there seem to be at least two ghosts here. Newspapers began reporting hauntings at the museum in the 1940s according to museum director Laura Foster. Frederic Remington is one of those ghosts. His full bodied apparition has been seen and objects do move around as though he is back at work in his studio.

The other spirit is believed to belong to a woman named Elena Ameriga Vespucci. You might recognize the name Ameriga from a previous This Month in History when we talked about America being named for Amerigo Vespucci, an Italian explorer and navigator who called what would become the Americas as the New World. Cartographer Martin Waldseemuller in 1507 wrote on a map of the New World the Latinized form of Amerigo, which was America and later cartographers followed suit. Elena was a direct descendant of Amerigo. She also ended up the the mistress of George Parish because of a card game. This is a legendary story, meaning that some of it may just be lore, but regardless, Elena is a fascinating character. She was raised in a Florentine convent until the age of seventeen. Then she was told that she would be moving on to serve as maid of honor to the Grand Duchess of Tuscany and she was having none of that. There was a secret group that had formed to obtain Italian independence called "La Jeune Italie" and she ran away and joined that group. In 1832, she took up arms and was described as having "great gallantry" and she suffered a severe injury at the hands of an Austrian dragoon. These political activities got her in trouble and she was exiled to France where she sought refuge at the court of France. 

When given the chance to head over to her family's name sake, she jumped and traveled to the United States where she petitioned for citizenship and a land grant. Elena was beautiful and very charming, so it didn't take long for here to insert herself into the political circles of  Washington, D.C. and she got Senator Thomas Hart Benton to petition the Senate on her behalf and he said, "She is without a country, without fortune, and without protection. She asks that we grant her a corner of the land which bears the name of her glorious forebear, and for the right of citizenship among those who call themselves Americans." Congress was actually forbidden to do that, so nothing came of this. 

The Countess of Blessington said of Elena that she was "interesting and original, full of animation…She possesses a certain wild, unsteady energy and cleverness…tormented with a constant desire to excite attention." She was described as "of fine features, symmetrically formed, of the perfect Italian style of beauty, with more of Juno’s characteristics than of Venus’ peculiarities in its excellency.  Her figure was commanding, full, strongly set up, and finely moulded"...her eyes were "wonderfully brilliant," and her hair “black as jet and of extraordinary length and abundance." With all of this in her favor, she decided to follow a suggestion made to her to go to the American people for help in starting her new life, so she visited several major cities in America and it was written , "Her path was strewn with roses, open hands, and confiding hearts." Even though it seemed that Elena would become a national icon, she abruptly left in 1840 and sailed for Europe declaring that she didn't want any money that wasn't a gift. This leads us to believe that perhaps she was told that money given to her was a loan or something. Whatever the case, the "New York Evening Star" did not take this ingratitude lightly and a bitter exposé was written about Elena and she was accused of having an affair with the Duke of Orleans. 

Elena would return to America though and this time she claimed to be Contessa Helene America. She had landed in Boston and started working the social circles there and no one seemed aware that she was Elena. They all fell under her spell once again. At some point she met a wealthy German merchant named George Parish. The two were living in what was described as "immoral intimacy" in Ogdensburg, New York. And here is where we get our legend. How Parish and Elena came to be together seems to be the result of a card game. Elena as Contessa had become the paramour of Martin Van Buren’s playboy son John. John liked to gamble and he and Parish got embroiled in an intense night of poker playing at the LeRay Hotel in Evans Mills, N.Y. John wasn't having any luck and he had lost all his money, so he put Vespucci up as a bet and wagered ownership of her on a toss of his last gold coin. Parish won the toss and he got the girl.

Now we're not sure if this story is true because Parish and Vespucci really seemed to love each other and spent twenty years together. Elena spent much of that time as a recluse because of all the wagging tongues about the two living in sin. The bliss would come to an end in 1856 when George's older brother died in Germany. His brother had been Baron von Leftonberg and now his family needed him to assume the roleand to find a bride. Elena wouldn't fit that bill, so he packed her up and sent her off to France with an allowance. The couple would never see each other again and Vespucci was devastated. She died in Paris in 1866. It was discovered by a man named C. Edwards Lester, while he was researching a book on the explorer Amerigo Vespucci that Elena's family were living in genteel poverty and that her stories about being raised in a convent, her time at the court of the Grand Duchess, her role in the Italian resistance, her intimacy with the French royal family were all just made up stories. She was actually a child that was hard to control whom he wrote had been "the mistress of some dozen men."  

Now how Elena gets connected to the museum is that Parish and her had lived at this house for those twenty years. This was the happiest time of her life and that is why her spirit seems to have come back across the ocean. In 2015, a psychic named Freda Gladle visited the museum and did a walk through with museum volunteer Donna Wright. Wright shared that she didn't believe any full-time spirits resided in the main museum, but she thought that she and Gladle did encounter some residual energy, although it sounds intelligent to us. They decided to try to communicate with the female spirit at the house and they did make a connection. When they asked if Elena had been won in a poker game, she responded very firmly, "I was not won in a poker game." This spirit claimed that she had actually lost money during the poker game and then had to quit because she had no money left. What was interesting about this investigation is that it was dovetailed with a simultaneous Clarkson University study of the air quality. Several undergraduate students, under the guidance of Shane Rogers, an associate professor of civil and environmental engineering, were investigating the claim that airborne organisms could provoke paranormal experiences.

Frederic Remington lived a larger than life kind of life and so it is no wonder that his spirit would continue on here on this plane of existence. Much of his belongings are located at the museum. Is it possible that he has returned to his belongings? And did Elena Ameriga Vespucci come back here as well? Is the Frederic Remington Museum of Art haunted? That is for you to decide! 

HGB Ep. 596 - Haunted Massillon, Ohio

Moment in Oddity - Hoss the Hairball

The original Mr. Potato Head included body parts, hats and the like that could be added to an actual potato or other vegetable. But what if those parts were added to a giant ball of hair? Let us introduce you to Hoss the Hairball, a Guiness Book record holding, ball of hair. Hoss was created in Ohio by hair stylist, Steve Warden. Warden's children had asked him for years to create a giant hairball. So in 2013, he began collecting his client's hair with that goal in mind. Warden even installed a chute in the floor of his salon to gather the hair. Little by little the hairstylist assembled what would come to be known as Hoss using liquid glue, spray adhesive and hairspray to keep its shape. The name Hoss was derived from the TV show Bonanza. In December of 2021, Hoss was weighed in by Guiness Book of World Records at a whopping 225.13 lbs. Hoss now travels with Ripley's Believe It or Not and has helped Ripley's raise more than $40,000 for charity organization Give Kids The World in Central Florida. Hoss sports big blue eyes, a large cowboy hat, toothy grin, a big nose and cow-print pants. People have donated to Hoss from around the world to create his rotund body and he continues to grow. Art can take numerous different forms, but creating a hairball that weighs more than the average man, certainly is odd.

This Month in History - Women's Rights Convention

In the month of July, on the 19th and 20th, in 1848, one of the first Woman's Rights Convention was held in Seneca Falls, New York. The event was organized by Elizabeth Stanton, Martha Wright, Jane Hunt, Lucretian Mott and Mary Ann McClintock, and was a crucial development in the fight for women's rights. Approximately 300 people were in attendance. Suffragists would later state that this convention was what truly launched the suffrage movement. It resulted in the drafting of the Declaration of Sentiments which was modeled after the Declaration of Independence. It laid out the fundamental equalities that women were demanding regarding political, social and economic rights declaring them as the same inalienable rights that men were given. One of the key elements of the Declaration of Sentiments called for women's right to vote. Although that endowment was not solidified until 1920 with the 19th amendment to the U.S. Constitution, the Declaration of Sentiments set into motion future activism and legal reforms for women. 

Haunted Massillon, (Mass uh lawn) Ohio (Suggested by: Alexis Balch)

Massillon, Ohio is located in Stark County along the Tuscarawas (tuh skr aa wuhz) River. This was a Quaker town and a canal town that grew and evolved as transportation changed throughout the country. Today, it has a thriving arts and culture scene that embraces its history. Several of the historic buildings in town have ghost stories connected to them. Join us for the history and hauntings of Massillon, Ohio. 

Massillon is referred to as a canal town and that is because the Ohio and Erie Canal played a crucial role in the city's growth. The city was founded on the banks of the Tuscarawas River as Kendal in 1812 by Thomas Rotch. Seafarering New Englanders joined him and many of them were Quakers, so the city was built with those values. A seaman named James Duncan came to the area in 1826 and established another city called Massillon, after French Catholic bishop Jean-Baptiste Massillon. The Ohio and Erie Canal was built through his land to connect Massillon to Cleveland and that was completed in 1832. Hiram and Marshall Wellman were merchants who came to Massillon and they built a warehouse along the canal. They sent out the word that they would pay cash for wheat and this brought farmers from everywhere and before long, Massillon was nicknamed "The Wheat City." *Fun Fact: Marshall Wellman was Jack London's grandfather.* The Port of Massillon thrived until the railroad arrived in 1852. Kendal and Massillon unified and incorporated in 1853. The Flood of 1913 inundated the city with water with floodwaters reaching the upper stories of buildings in the downtown area. The railroad tracks were destroyed and trains were washed away. The Ohio and Erie Canal was pretty much done after this flood. The building of viaducts helped with future flooding threats and saved the city from becoming a Rust Belt shell. The economy diversified and the city has remained resilient. 

So yeah, that's it for the history, nothing else major. Okay, okay, so Alexis, who suggested this city to us mentioned that apparently football is kinda big here. Massillon is renowned for its fervent high school football culture and that is because they have a community history deeply rooted in football. They love there Massillon Tigers team. There is apparently a strong rivalry with the Canton McKinley Bulldogs and it is said this is one of the oldest and most storied rivalries in high school football. Massillon leads the series 76-53-5. The Massillon Tigers were an early professional football team that was founded in 1903 and played in the Ohio League winning five championship titles in a row. The NFL began as the APFA in 1920 and the Tigers opted not to join. They stayed independent until they folded in 1923. The Massillon Washington High School assumed the Tiger as their school mascot. Paul Brown graduated from the school in 1925 and he returned to coach the football team in 1932 and he stayed on as coach for nine years with an unbelievable 80-8-2 record. There was a 35-game winning streak in there. Brown would go on to be the first head coach of the Cleveland Browns and he did that for 17 seasons. Interestingly, the Browns have no logo and yes, they are named for Coach Brown, which I only just learned while researching this. The stadium the football team plays in is named for Paul Brown. Massillon finished in the top 4 of ESPN's Titletown USA in 2008.

Before we get into true hauntings, we wanted to touch on the Woman in Black Panic that hit Massillon in 1895. Author Chris Woodyard brought this to our attention on his blog "Haunted Ohio." The Independent wrote in September of 1895, "Some little time ago Peter Ertle stood on the corner of Prospect and Plum Streets conversing in low but impassioned tones with a young woman who listened with an eagerness that did not prevent her from taking mental note of a woman in black, who appeared with mincing steps and hovered near as though to listen. The first impulse of the couple thus rudely approached was one of indignation, but a second glance evoked curiosity, as it showed that the creature wore garments belonging to quite another generation and its head seemed ridiculously small, no larger than Peter Ertle’s manly fist. When the interest shifted and the young people began to scrutinize the strange apparition, the latter gathered up its skirts and floated rather than walked in the direction of Cedar Street. Mr. Ertle and his companion followed, somewhat gingerly, it must be confessed, and after following it through the labyrinths of Kendal town returned again to their corner and resumed the thread of their purely personal discussion. And then something strange occurred. 

Although they so stood that every avenue of approach was under their eyes, they became conscious all at once of a presence close at hand, and turning, discovered to their amazement this same woman, man or spirit, grinning and listening as before. Again it fled and again it strangely disappeared. Mr. Ertle submits the opinion that this woman in black is a sure-enough woman, afflicted with some malady of the head, which causes her to roam the streets at night. But Peter Ertle and that particular young woman no longer carry on conversations in low and impassioned tones at the corner of Prospect Street and Plum." The article continues with saying that Peter Ertle saw this Woman in Black for over three years. There was a belief that this wasn't a real spirit and the article continued, "While it is unwise in these piping times of peace, for real or imitation ghosts to go stalking forth, they undoubtedly have the right to parade the streets, if they so desire, as long as they refrain from committing deeds of a disorderly character or of violence. It does not appear that the “woman in black” has misbehaved herself very seriously, and there is therefore no urgent necessity on the part of anybody to shoot promiscuously at objects which may or may not be mysterious. Young persons whose enthusiasm and courage are of a soda water variety should not be entrusted with fire arms for the purpose of exterminating ghosts or any other animate objects. Revolvers are made for policemen and Wild West cowboys. Other people have no earthly excuse for carrying them, and their possession entails more trouble than it does good. Parents are warned that many of their young sons are inclined to disagree with these doctrines, and it is their duty to assist in bringing about a complete disarmament. Under conditions that give assurance of personal security, let the ghost hunting proceed." Seven days later, the Woman in Black was revealed and The Independent reported, " Canton, Sept. 14. The mysterious “woman in black” proves to be Mrs. Libold, of Canton, who lives opposite the Yohe House. Frequently during the summer Mrs. Libold has visited friends in Massillon, and not being aware that she presented a frightful appearance to the superstitious she has crossed Prospect and Plum Streets on her way to see them. On one occasion, no doubt the night that Peter Ertle and the young lady with whom he was talking first reported the ghostly spectre in black, Mrs. Libold says she was followed quite a distance by a young couple after she had crossed Prospect Street. 'I remember the instance well,' said Mrs. Libold, 'for I was rather frightened myself. I had called on friends in Plum Street and remained there later than I should, for I wished to spend a few moments with acquaintances in Center Street. I started for the latter place and walked rather fast. When I reached Prospect Street, instead of turning up to North I walked straight up Plum Street and then through the alley in the rear of the Steese residence to North. I then noticed that I was being followed by the young man and lady and walked faster. When I reached Hamel’s they had retired and I returned on North Street. The two walked past me and stared at me so closely that I thought they must have taken me for someone else. I then took the 10:30 car for Canton.' When informed that she had been taken for the ghost and had badly frightened several persons she was astonished but greatly amused." 

Massillon Public Library 

The Massillon Public Library is located at 208 Lincoln Way East. The Massillon library started as the McClymonds Public Library in 1899. The first library was housed in the donated home of Nahum and Esther Russell, which was located on Fourth Street. The library was named for J.W. McClymond who had provided a $20,000 endowment. Founder James Duncan built his home in the 1830s and the house was later owned by Dr. J.P. and Clara Barrick. Clara died in the home in 1909 and the house passed to Clara's son Frank Lee Baldwin and his wife Annie. Annie died in the house in 1931 and she had bequeathed the home to the city to be used as a museum or library. This opened as the Baldwin Museum with many artifacts and some artwork in 1933. In 1934, snakes  and other creatures were added as was a reproduction of a coal mine in the basement. In 1935, a battle ensued about closing the museum and moving the library to the house. The library was moved to the house and a new building was built for the museum. The library is a really beautiful red brick building that was designed by architect Albrecht. There is a large rotunda with two wings, with one of those wings being the Duncan house. The interior features tall ceilings and terrazzo marble floors. 

The library is said to be haunted and staff and visitors have all reported experiences. A security camera caught an interesting develop at the witching hour. Right at 3am, the elevator took itself up to the third floor and opened. A bright light was seen coming from inside the elevator. And then a security camera caught the same thing again and again. It has happened many times. Director Sherie Brown has worked at the library since 1979 and she shared with The Independent an experience she had in 2011. She said she was working in her office that was located in the wing that had been Duncan's house after the library had closed for the day. Someone walked past her office door and she was startled because she thought she was the only employee in the building. She called out and got no response, so she went to see where this person had gone and she found no else in the library. A custodian was cleaning one night and heard what he described as the tapping of a cane in the attic. A patron claimed that someone unseen pushed her. And staff members have been hit by books flying off the shelves. There are also claims of hearing disembodied footsteps and the nose picture of a distinctive perfume. 

Brian Fain is the co-founder of Massillon Paranormal Research Association and they have investigated at the library. The Massillon Independent reported in 2018 the group, "During a six-year period, the group conducted nine investigations at the library. The paranormal investigators have captured a few pieces of evidence to support the claim. Fain's sister-in-law was conducting an EVP session when she asked if the ghost helped the staff out at night when no one was there. When they played back the recording, a woman is heard answering the question with a 'no.' On another occasion, Fain and team members were in the reference area of the library near the fireplace. The two were joking that the chairs were very comfortable. Fain said he couldn't read siting there or he would likely fall asleep. When they played the recording back, a voice could be heard faintly saying 'they sleep here sometimes.' 

The Lions Lincoln Theater

The Lion's Lincoln Theater is located at 156 Lincoln Way E. and was built in 1915 by grocer John McLain. The architect was Guy Tilden and the facade has a beautiful lighted marquee. The interior isn't real fancy and this was originally a motion picture theater that now hosts performing arts. The building is preparing to undergo many interior and exterior upgrades, which was announced just here in July 2025. The theater started with 979 seats and had a Hillgreen-Lane straight pipe organ. The Schine Circuit Inc. took over the theater in 1927 and they installed a Wurlitzer 2 manual, 7 ranks style EX-opus 1560 theatre organ. That organ would be removed in 1938 by Warner Bros. Circuit Management Corp. who had acquired the theater in 1931. The Lincoln Theatre was sold in the 1980s to the Massillon Lions Club and they still operate it today with Eric Myers serving as the theater's Executive Director.

The theater is said to be haunted and starting in 2014, it has hosted an event called Haunted: Locked in at the Lincoln. Jim Fravel was the Director of Performing Arts at the theater at that time and he told The Canton Repository, "We've had other ghost hunter groups come and spend the night in the theater and they have recorded amazing results. The Massillon Ghost Hunters Society and the North Canton Paranormal Society have both verified the existence of paranormal activity in the theater. Some of the members have recorded voices and EVPs (electronic voice phenomenon). It's never been anything scary and they've never found any mean spirits." The stories here claim that one of the spirits here goes by the name Red and this entity appears as a shadow, causes cold spots and likes to move things around. Disembodied voices are heard in the stairwells. 

Five Oaks Mansion

The Five Oaks Mansion is located at 210 Fourth Street NE and was the home of the man whom we mentioned in regards to the beginnings of the library, J. Walter McClymonds. Five Oaks was named for the five oaks on the property and built in 1892 as designed by architect, Charles F. Schweinfurth in the Gothic and Romenesque styles.  The street it was built on was known at the turn-of-the-century  as "The Showplace of America." It was said to be the architect's best work. The exterior featured towering chimneys, an arched portico and a corner turret tower. The interior featured Tiffany glass, chandeliers, exotic woods that were beautifully carved and there was also gold and silver leaf embossing. The house was filled with Victorian furniture as well. In September of 1919, the house became the meeting place for the Massillon Women’s Club, which had been formed to support the WWI effort. The house was registered on the National Register of Historic Places in 1972. Haunting activity included hearing a woman singing, a statue that moves on its own, the smell of a cigar and full-bodied apparitions. The North Ohio Paranormal Scientific Society investigated in 2010 and reported feeling "spider webs" across their faces and arms, hair touched, touches on the neck and cold air on the neck, heart racing and dizziness.

Kozmo's Grill

Kozmo's Grill is located at 37 First Street SW. Kozmo's was opened by three guys, an ex-beer salesman, an ex-medical swab manufacturer and an ex-CPA in 2005 in a building that has been here for 150 years. The name comes from Kramer of Seinfeld. His first name was Cosmo with a "C." The restaurant has a K instead. The men renovated the space, embracing its history by highlighting the tin ceilings, exposed brick and refinishing the original wood floors. A wood stone hearth is the heart of the restaurant and is used to make pizza, cookies, fruit cobbler and dips. Before Kozmo's was here, this was Coppers Bar & Cafe. Sherri Brake had investigated here when it was Coppers and she writes in her book "Haunted Stark County," (pg. 86)

Kendal and Massillon City Cemeteries

When the city of Kendal was founded, the Kendal Cemetery was the first burial ground established in the city of Massillon. The Kendal Cemetery was founded in 1811. When the Black Plague came through the city, a mass burial pit was dug and people who died from the plague were thrown into it. There are legends that claim some of them were still alive. Some of these mass graves had up to 40 bodies. In 1848, it fell into disuse and then disrepair. Some bodies were moved to a new cemetery opened as the Massillon City Cemetery in 1846 at 1827 Erie Street South. We read that the former Kendal Cemetery is now just a grassy field at Ninth Street NE and Andrew Avenue NE and that a white urn with a few flowers planted inside is all that remains as a marker for the cemetery. There is no sign. No headstones. But bones still remain below the soil. Homes near the former cemetery are said to be haunted and its no wonder. Local historian Bob Bratton had grown up in a house on the 200 block of Ninth Street. "The Alliance Review" talked to Bratton in 2017 and reported, "As a young boy, Bratton remembers waking up one night to see a square-headed silhouette sitting at the end of his bed. He never told anyone of this occurrence. Twenty years later, his younger brother occupied Bratton's old bedroom and also awoke one night to see the same figure with the perfectly square head sitting at the foot of his bed." Ohhh, the square headed ghost! That's a first for us.

The Massillon City Cemetery has 24,000 burials. One of the people moved here from the Kendal Cemetery was Captain Mayhew Folger. Folger had been the Captain of the Topaz and on one of his voyages in 1808, they rediscovered Pitcairn Island. For those unfamiliar with Pitcairn Island, this is where the mutineers from the Bounty - you know, Mutiny on the Bounty - settled. That happened in 1789. So Folger ends up here in 1808 and only one of the mutineers was still alive, Alexander Smith, whose real name was John Adams. Adams gave Captain Folger the Bounty's azimuth compass and Larcum Kendall K2 marine chronometer. The group had burned the Bounty to escape detection. Captain Folger moved to Kendal, Ohio with his family in 1813. He became the first postmaster of Massillon in 1828 and died later that year. He is said to haunt the Massillon Cemetery with balls of light frequently showing up in photos taken with his headstone. Tour guide, author and investigator Sherri Brake shares that when the Captain was dug up from Kendal, his coffin was empty and that his body had been grave robbed. Not sure if that is true and they buried an empty coffin in Massillon City Cemetery or just put up a cenotaph. Maybe that is why he is haunting the place.

Massillon Psychiatric Center

The founder of the city, James Duncan, had owned the land where the Massillon State Hospital for the Insane was built in 1898. The cottage that Duncan built here when he was grazing sheep was used as a dwelling by the hospital until 1956. Ohio Governor William McKinley, whom would later become president, is the one who suggested that the 240 acres of this plot be given to the state to build the hospital. The cottage design for mental hospitals had taken hold in the country at this time as a better way to treat the mentally ill. The Kirkbride Plan was losing favor. In honor of McKinley, the first hall built here was named for him and covered 52,000 square feet. Three hundred patients were moved in after the hospital opened and Dr. A.B. Richardson was the superintendent. 

Ironically, the best superintendent at the hospital was named Arthur Hyde. He took over in 1918 and would remain in that position until 1954. He knew each patient by name and treated them with respect. It is said he did more for the mentally ill than anyone else in Ohio. A trolley was built between the city of Massillon and the hospital. The hospital continued to expand adding forty buildings that included a laundry, power house, boiler house, kitchen and bakery, dining hall, infirmiry building, stroehouse and residences for patients and employees. By 1950, there were 365 employees and 3,100 patients. As the 1970s brought other theories on treatment, patients were slowly transferred out of the hospital to other facilities. The hospital changed its name to the Massillon Psychiatric Center after that and today is known as the Heartland Behavioral Health Center. In October of 2024, federal grants were used to begin a clean-up at the hospital. 

McKinley Hall closed and has sat empty. People have claimed that this is the most haunted location on the property. Lights flicker inside when no one is inside. There have been sightings of a ghostly boy inside. He was seen by nurses through the years and they claimed he darted through the halls at night. Sherri Brake says that in 2005, she was taking a tour group into the hall and this group included a local reporter and photographer. The photographer caught an image that looked like a blurry little boy and there were no children on the tour. 

Doctors Hospital

Doctors Hospital in Massillon was located at 400 Austin Avenue NW before it was demolished. This hospital was built in the early 1960s and ran until 2008. Five doctors and a businessman are the team that formed to build the hospital. The building was shaped like and airplane with a main corridor and two wings that included 48 beds. The hospital was expanded several times over the years and ended up being 300,000 square feet. The hospital offered all services from regular doctors visits to emergency care and surgery. There was intensive care units and a maternity ward. The hospital went into decline after merging with Massillon Community Hospital in 2006 to become Affinity Medical Center and all serves were eventually moved to the Massillon facility. The Stark County morgue remained until 2009 and the building sat vacant until it was demolished in 2019. 

Doctors Hospital was said to be haunted. One of the spirits here was said to be a nurse's aid who died from a heart attack in the hospital. He liked to hum and so disembodied humming was heard. A misty apparition has been seen. Water faucets would turn on and off by themselves, even as staff watched it happen. Nurses claimed to hear their names being called when no one was around. There was one room that was said to be the most haunted. The legend behind it was that an elderly woman had cursed the room before she died. Patients staying in the room would complain that an elderly woman would enter their room and pull their covers off of them and tell them to leave her room. Coldness would often fill the room - but then, you have to wonder if these people had ever been in a hospital. The freaking place is always freezing! A hospital administrator wanted to prove the stories wrong, so he stayed the night in the room, but he fled it around 2am. He then had the room sealed off and no patients were ever assigned the room again. 

A story shared with 12 News goes, "Another tale takes place in labor and delivery. According to Miller, an expectant mother was in distress. Her young nurse went in search of a doctor for help. She encountered an older physician in the hallway who barked orders and walked away. Not long after, a superior berated the young staffer for administering drugs without doctor's orders. The young RN offered up a description of the mysterious doctor. Her description eerily matched that of a hospital doctor who had died years earlier." 

Massillon, Ohio is a historic town oozing with small town charm and football. There is plenty of interesting architecture and it would seem that there are plenty of ghosts too. Are these location in Massillon haunted? That is for you to decide! 

HGB Ep. 595 - Queen Anne Hotel

Moment in Oddity - Smooth Head Blobfish

There are many strange looking creatures that lurk in the depths of our oceans. Some, presumably even yet to be discovered. There is one very peculiar fish that was discovered in 2003 that is found deep in the sea off of the southeastern coast of Australia. It is known as the smooth-head blobfish. Its neighborhood ranges from 2,000 to 3,900 feet deep and its looks are like that saying, 'a face that only a mother could love'. Strangely, it resembles a gelatinous faced old man with a very large nose. The unique creatures do not have a swim bladder and their body density is slightly lower than water which allows them to float above the sea floor. They also do not have a full skeleton which also lends to their blob like appearance, especially when brought to the surface. Its head makes up 40 percent of its body mass. They are usually found around one foot in length and it is said that they can live up to 130 years. Although we enjoy the creepy at History Goes Bump, please only search images for this creature if you dare. You have been warned. We don't know if the smooth-head blobfish would win the ugliest fish in the world title, but it certainly is odd. 

This Month in History - World's Largest Floating Dock (Suggested by: Duey Oxberger)

In the month of July, on the 4th, in 1869, the world's largest floating dry dock began the longest spanse of its voyage from Porto Santo, Portugal to Bermuda. The Royal Navy stationed in Bermuda needed the dry dock for repairing its ships, but Bermuda's bedrock consisted of too much porous sandstone which prevented the building of a dry dock on site.  The structure was built in England and then began its incredible journey to Bermuda. In our modern era, the dry dock resembled a giant half pipe, like a skateboarder's dream, courtesy of Tony Hawk. The method of delivering the giant iron structure was a feat in and of itself. When the dry dock departed Porto Santo it was towed by iron warships HMS Warrior and HMS Black Prince. It was guided by the wooden paddle frigate, HMS Terrible from behind. The U shaped dry dock itself had its own sail hoisted in the middle of the structure to assist in its own propulsion. A portion of the voyage took the structure through The Narrows at Ireland Island where threats of damage by reefs were high. The dry dock was carefully maneuvered by the Terrible with gunboats HMS Vixen and HMS Viper lashed to each quarter of the structure. On July 31st 1869, the largest floating dry dock of the time was secured in its final resting place of its journey. It served the Royal Navy in Bermuda for over three decades before being retired in 1906. 

Queen Anne Hotel

The Queen Anne Hotel in San Francisco has been a fixture of the Pacific Heights neighborhood for more than 100 years. As the name reveals, this is an old Victorian styled house - a big one! Before it was the boutique hotel it is today, it was a school for girls run by headmistress Mary Lake. Mary loved the place and seems to have returned in the afterlife. She is one of the reasons many feel that this is the most haunted hotel in San Francisco. Join us for the history and hauntings of the Queen Anne Hotel. 

The Ohlone People were believed to have arrived in the area somewhere around 500 AD and they were here for thousands of years. They were still there when the Spanish arrived. They faced slavery and death. The Spanish founded San Francisco in 1776 and they named it Yerba Buena, after a plant that was growing in abundance in the area. The common name for this plant is Oregon Tea. Mexico declared independence from Spain in 1821 and that was it for the Spanish. The Ohlone continued to stay in San Francisco after the Spanish left. The city would be renamed San Francisco in 1846, after Saint Francis of Assisi. American settlers started coming out to California and the Gold Rush that ran between 1848 to 1855 caused a boom for San Francisco. And by boom, we mean 800 residents to 50,000. An earthquake and fire in 1906 hit the city hard, killing 3,000 people and destroying 80% of the city. The city rebuilt and is today one of the most populous cities in California. The World Fair in 1915 showcased the city's progress and prosperity. The Golden Gate Bridge was completed in 1937. Beatniks came and the counterculture made San Francisco its capitol. Today, the city is successful in business and has several haunted locations, with Alcatraz probably being the most popular and haunted, but the Queen Anne Hotel is said to be the most haunted hotel in the city. 

The hotel started out as a girls’ boarding school and was built in 1890. The money for the endeavor came from Senator James G. Fair. This man has been described as "one of the great villains of Wild West Lore." To give the listeners an idea of how people felt about this guy, everyone called him "Slippery Jim." Fair had been born in Ireland in 1831 and emigrated to America in 1843, landing in Illinois. When the Gold Rush began, he headed for Nevada - to another haunted city we have covered in the past, Virginia City. There he found success working as a mine superintendent and eventually, in 1869, was running the Bonanza Firm at the Comstock Lode silver rush. The Bonanza Firm was a partnership Fair started with three other men and they hit a massive silver vein they dubbed the "Big Bonanza." The men themselves were called the Bonanza Kings and this strike made them incredibly rich. They used some of their profits to found the Bank of Nevada in San Francisco. Fair himself branched out into the railroad and established the South Pacific Coast Railroad in 1876. This railway committed to laying down track from Newark, California through San Francisco Bay  to the Santa Cruz Mountains. Fair would move to San Francisco in 1887 after he served in the US Senate from 1881 to 1887. He died in 1894.

So the listeners are probably asking, what caused this guy to have such a bad reputation? Well, like many politicians, he used his vast wealth of $50 million to get himself a seat in the Senate. Early in his mining career, in 1857, Fair was sued along with two other men for infringing on another mining company's claim. What Fair and his buddies had done was to get a shareholder of the other company to claim he was working as an agent of a young black woman and he sold the land to Fair's group as a double deal. They used this woman because blacks couldn't testify in court. The group still lost and had to give up the claim, but they only had to pay the court costs and then give the plaintiffs $1 out of the $100,000 they were seeking. But it revealed that Fair was willing to do things in an underhanded way. He was absolutely ruthless and disliked by most people. 

His nickname of "Slippery Jim" was inspired by his bad credit and came about in 1861 when he was at Angels Mining Camp. He was often heavily in debt at the camp and suppliers would check with his bank before extending him credit. His growing list of unpaid bills had them calling him slippery. Another story about him goes back to his management days in the mines. A group of miners were taking a break and he walked up to them and asked for a light. There was no smoking allowed underground, but since this was their supervisor, the miners assumed that it was okay with him if they smoked. After all, he WAS smoking. So they enjoyed a smoke break with him. Later in the day, they were all handed dismissals for breaking the rules, signed by Fair himself. Not only did Fair treat his employees poorly, he was an absolute rat to his wife, Theresa Rooney.

The couple had met before Fair had made his money and he was just a young miner. She was the daughter of Carson Hill boarding house owners Thomas and Alice Rooney. Fair married Theresa in 1861. He was described as “devilishly charming” and his charm went out to more than just Theresa. He was a notorious womanizer and this got worse when he was in D.C. serving as a Senator. Theresa had had enough at that point and filed for divorce from San Francisco in 1883. And this erupted into a nationwide scandal. The papers carried all the treacherous details. Theresa’s attorney tracked down two women who claimed to have affairs with Fair, a San Francisco brothel owner and a lady of the evening. She won the largest divorce settlement in the country's history at that time. She was awarded $4.25 million, the mansion on Pine and Jones and custody of their three young children.

It was after the divorce that Fair seems to have taken up with a woman named Mary Lake, who would be the headmistress for the boarding school that becomes the Queen Anne Hotel. So now the listeners understand how this man came to finance the all-girls school. Mary was born in Little Falls, N.Y., in 1849 to Helen and Delos Lake. The family decided to move across the country to San Francisco when Mary was still a toddler. Delos opened up a law practice and became very wealthy, building a mansion and sending Mary to the best schools. She focused on teaching and her early career focused on grammar schools in the city. Eventually, Mary desired to open her own place, so in 1889, she started the Lake Seminary and while this was a really nice private boarding school for girls, she wanted something more lavish. Enter James Fair and the construction of a gorgeous Queen Anne styled building at the corner of Sutter and Octavia in 1890. The building had 31 private bedrooms, a dining room and library. The exterior featured large bay windows and elaborate ornamentation. And the paint style that it still has today was described as the painted lady style. Around 100 girls attended the school.

Now remember how Fair’s divorce made all the newspapers? Well, this little affair was the talk of the town as well. The San Francisco Chronicle ran the headline “CUPID AND MR. FAIR” on October 30, 1891. The article revealed, “The pupils in Miss Lake’s establishment at 1534 Sutter Street have whispered it back and forth and giggled, smiled, simpered and laughed outright for a fortnight. What made it all the more interesting was the story that Miss Lake had been absent from her school for a time and that Mr. Fair had not been seen on Montgomery Street in eight days.” Fair and Lake both denied the rumors and Mary claimed that her enemies had made up these lies to drag her name through the mud. She said that she had only seen the Senator a handful of times. When the rumors went further and claimed that the two had secretly married, Fair went on to point out that Lake was a woman of great esteem, but that she certainly wasn’t his wife. And maybe rumors of a love affair were just that, but one has to wonder why former Senator Fair would want to finance a boarding school for a few rich girls. Some claim that maybe Fair was friends with Delos Lake who was now a judge and so he did it as a favor to him. And some records show that Lake paid rent to Fair at $400 a month.

For six years, the school ran successfully, but the Panic of 1896 swept across the nation after silver reserves dropped in value and the economic downturn shuttered the school. Everything had to go, so Mary sold everything with a heavy heart. The ten pianos that had filled the home with music were the toughest to let go. The whole affair broke her heart and perhaps that is why she died eight years later at the age of 55. She literally died on her 55th birthday, while living at her half-sister’s house in Montclair, New Jersey. After her death, the local paper wrote, “She was possessed of a keen wit and a warm, magnetic personality which endeared her to the hearts of all who had the good fortune to know her intimately. Though her pupils during all the years of her teaching were counted by the hundreds, she never forgot one.” It continued with talk of the library at the school, “Mary’s school library [was} different. There [were] all the usual, high-brow classics from Hawthorne, Moliere and Bulwer-Lytton. And, mixed in, romance novels from Jane Austen, tales of growing up from Louisa May Alcott and the many adventures of Alice in Wonderland. For who has not loved to linger in fairylands and wonderful Aladdin scenes, and wander in the realms of fancy? And Miss Lake thoroughly believes in the cultivation of the imagination of children.”

James Fair, as we said, had already passed two years before the Panic, but the building remained in the Fair estate, so whoever was in charge of the estate at the time decided to rent the place and the first taker was the Cosmos Club, which was a men’s club for the rich and powerful in San Francisco. This was formed in 1881 and incorporated in 1883 and had 215 members. Some claim that this was a secret society of sorts, but it certainly was one of the “Old Money” clubs. A Medium article says of the Cosmos Club in Washington, D.C., “Members [had to have] made noteworthy contributions to the arts, sciences, or public service, thereby fostering a community of intellectual discourse and enlightenment.” Decorum and discretion were expected and there were initiation ceremonies passed down through the generations. It’s a bunch of rich men who can do whatever they want and swear each other to secrecy, so one can only imagine how very different this was from the young girls who had inhabited it before.

The house fell into disrepair as it changed hands until it was purchased by the Queen Anne Hotel Company and renovated and reopened as the Queen Anne Hotel in the 1980s. The hotel features a variety of room styles, event space and runs more like a bed and breakfast with a complimentary deluxe continental breakfast. The lobby is like a time capsule. One really feels as though they have stepped back into the Victorian era with this large sitting room filled with antique furniture, sparkling chandeliers, floor-to-ceiling formal drapes, a piano and a fireplace. Afternoons feature tea and sherry in the Parlor and Library. The Parlor Room also has a painting of Lillie Hitchcock Coit, who was a prominent San Francisco socialite in the day. She had been fascinated with firefighters from a young age and became a patron of the volunteer firefighters of the city. Coit also was a benefactor of the Coit Tower, which is a well known structure that she built to beautify the city. Some of the rooms feature canopy beds and all rooms have period pieces along with contemporary amenities.

It truly is amazing that this beautiful building has not only weathered time, but also the earthquake and fire. Could it be that it was protected by someone unseen? Mary Lake loved the school. This had been her dream. She died in 1904 and people claim her spirit returned to the building, so she quite possibly was here when the tragedies struck San Francisco. Claims are that she haunts Room 410 the most, but there are enough stories about the entire hotel that one can imagine that she wanders around and there seems to be residual energy from the girls left behind. EVPs have captured the giggling of little girls. People claim to feel cold spots in the hallways. Strange reflections show up in the mirrors in the hotel. Staff and guests have seen the full-bodied apparition of Mary dressed in period clothing. Others describe the appearance of a mist. Bags seem to unpack themselves at time and Mary is credited with that. Room 410 is said to be the most haunted room in the hotel. The hauntings are referred to as “friendly.” A guest staying in Room 410 awoke one morning and was stunned to find himself on the floor with his bedding neatly tucked around him.

People also claim that the spirit of the Voodoo Queen of San Francisco, Mary Ellen Pleasant, might be here as well because she once lived across the street. Pleasant was probably the most powerful black woman during the Gold Rush in San Francisco. She had inherited a large sum of money from her first husband after he died and set off from New England to California in 1852. We should mention that her husband was abusive and he just may have been poisoned and before Pleasant arrived in New England, she had been in New Orleans where she learned voodoo from Marie Laveau. Mary Ellen invested her money in services for the miners after she got to San Francisco, like laundries and boardinghouses. Pleasant donated a lot of her money to the black community, from churches to the black press. She took a case all the way to the Supreme Court when she was denied service by a street car and won. Pleasant was an ardent abolitionist and her headstone states “A friend of John Brown.”  She built a mansion with her business partner Thomas Bell and lived there with him and his wife and children, acting the part of domestic servant even though she partially owned the place. The mansion was dubbed the House of Mystery and rumors claimed there were tunnels running beneath it. She eventually lost much of her wealth, which was somewhere over $1 million, and was said to wander around outside the former Bell Mansion until her death. 

The former home site now hosts the Landmark Apartments and Healing Arts Center. Before that, this was the Greens’ Eye Hospital that was founded by brothers, Drs. Aaron S. and Lewis D. Green. They had emigrated to San Francisco from Latvia to intern with Stanford Hospitals in 1906. They were inventors of various corneal treatments and pioneers in eye surgery. They built the two-story hospital in 1928. There are claims that there are hauntings here. Possibly from the hospital, but also maybe from Pleasant’s time here. People claim her spirit wanders around the Queen Anne Hotel and the nearby eucalyptus trees that she planted. The San Francisco News ran this story on October 14, 1935 about Pleasant, whom people called Mammy, "For 25 years during the past [nineteenth] century she tyrannized the somber and inscrutable Bell mansion, with its fringe of eucalyptus, at 1661 Octavia-st. What old-timer does not remember the lean, erect, shrewd-eyed Negress with her old black straw bonnet, gold hoop earrings, spotless kerchief fastened with a winking moss-agate brooch, moving among the stalls of the old Sutter-st market? Mammy, who was reputed the wickedest woman in San Francisco, who figured in every important lawsuit for nearly half a century, but who lied so cunningly that the most astute lawyer never tripped her. Mary Ellen Pleasant had an uncanny way of chancing upon gossipers and professed to the skeletons in the closets of every high-ranking family in the city. Folks took care not to snub her. You never knew when she would find out something about you. The history of Mammy Pleasant and her hold on Thomas and Teresa Bell will perhaps always be shrouded in secrecy. For although she had been offered $50,000 tell what she knew after the death of Mr. Bell and her grim rift with Teresa Bell over a property settlement in 1899, loyalty was one of Mammy’s virtues. People said she was a blackmailer, a procuress, a thief, a horsewhipper of children—who was also capable of generosity and infinite gentleness—and that she had been a New Orleans slave whose master had freed her for “certain reasons.” She had hypnotic powers over women and brewed love philters which she sold to wealthy damsels. Among the latter was Sarah Althea Hill. She helped Sarah Althea bury Senator Sharon’s coat and waistcoat in a cemetery one dark night—assuring Sarah Althea that this procedure would revive the sulking senator’s dead love for her. It was common legend that Mammy was in league with Blind Bill, the Bell butler. When Thomas Bell died from a fall over the banisters of his own house and his son Fred was the victim of a mysterious assault in the house, tongues clacked unrestrainedly. Before he died, Tom S. Burns, who was Teresa Bell’s old notary public, swore he knew Mammy had killed Thomas Bell by giving him drugged port wine and pushing him over the banister. Little wonder when mammy died in 1904 at the age of 89, and Teresa Bell sold the “House of Mystery,” which subsequently became a select boarding house, that folks labeled the place haunted." 

Back to the Queen Anne Hotel, a group of three paranormal investigators stayed overnight in Room 307 and since one of the haunting experiences is said to be having your bags unpacked for you, they left a backpack full of equipment and other things on the bed, along with a REM Pod on the bed and they left the room. They had also set up one of their cell phones to pick up any activity on video and when they came back, the backpack hadn't been touched, but the video revealed the REM Pod going off. As they watched the video, the REM Pod went off again and it lasted for probably 30 seconds. A fan in the room also turned on by itself. They left again with the REM Pod on the bed and video captured it going off several times on its own. They got out an EMF detector and it started going off and then they heard a knock coming from a desk in the room. So they didn't get anything crazy and nothing with any valuable communication, but there definitely seemed to be something messing with the equipment. 

Sam and Colby stayed in Room 410 around three years ago. Two girls joined them named Katrina and Stas (stahz). Before they went to the hotel, they stopped at a museum for about 30 minutes and left all of their bags and stuff in a car on the street. In San Francisco. This was a hatch back. You listeners can imagine what happened. So, the boys had to make this video with a very basic camera and no equipment because it was all taken. But we like old school anyway. At one point in the night, Katrina's back was touched and maybe this was because the head mistress was trying to get her to stand up straight - posture you know!

The FootTracker Blog participated in an investigation in 2011 and wrote, "As we are in room 410, perhaps the large crowd was too much for Miss Mary Lake, we did not see a full body apparition. However, as we stayed in the room longer, we noticed the chair at the end of the bed has a crease on it (and was getting more apparent), just like someone is sitting on it….hmmm." They also felt a cold spot in that area as well.
djsreddit wrote on reddit in 2015, " My mom has always been into the supernatural and she sparked that interest in me as well. We saw the Queen Anne hotel on tv as being a haunted place that people have experienced encounters with something. We lived nearby, about an hour away, at the time so we called and booked the room of the deceased women that reaches out to people who stay there. Fast-forward to that night, we toured the surrounding neighborhood and grabbed dinner. Finally we get back to the room, i set the cameras up to record as we sleep to try and catch any activity. Once they're prepped i went to shower while my mom watched tv. I finished my shower and went and laid on the bed to watch some tv. I had my arm hanging off the edge of the bed while laying there talking to my mom when out of nowhere i had the feeling I've read others describe as the warmth being sucked from your body. I immediately pulled back from the cold and tried to feel the area my arm was again and it immediately cooled my arm again. At this point i started to speak to tell my mom, but it was so surreal that i didn't know what to say so i tried sit up off the side of the bed. It was at this point that i felt something push on the center of my chest that was so cold that i could define what was firmly pushing me back onto the bed as a hand. I burst into tears, not sobbing, but water was pouring from my eyes out of fear. My mom was frantically asking me what was wrong because all she could see was me laying down quickly. I tried to calm myself enough to tell her what was going on, but before i could explain, the hand removed the pressure from my chest and it was as if nothing had happened. The freezing cold area where my arm was hanging had disappeared. I calmed down and explained everything to my mom. She said that we should just leave and i said no. I was dead set on getting video after we fell asleep. Why? Because this wasn't my first experience and i really just wanted something i could show others around me to try and give some type of proof. I had to set alarms because at the time the tapes were only able to record 2-3 hours at a time and needed to be changed. Our initial experiment was to just push the blankets on the floor and go to bed. We did this because there are multiple accounts of people not only seeing an entity, but that they wake up with the blankets covering people up to their neck when they went to bed without the blanket covering them. I woke up around 3am to my alarm. First issue is that i set an alarm for every two hours. We went to bed at 10pm and my alarms were loud ringtones. Nothing that i could've slept through. The second thing i noticed is that the blanket that we pushed off the bed was now covering my mom and I all the way to our necks. The blanket was smoothly covering us as if someone had pulled it out of the dryer and shook it out and set it perfectly on top of us. I woke my mom to tell her, but she was completely out. She would wake up, but then fall right back to sleep. I got up to change the tape and then went back to bed. When we woke up the next day everything felt normal. Nothing was out of place minus the blanket and nothing followed us after we left, but there were more than a few photos that show what could be orbs floating nearby me in the room. I didn't catch anything on video, but i also slept through my alarms so who know what was going on around us that night." 

Susie Milwaukee wrote on TripAdvisor in 2017, "My family actually stayed in a lovely corner room with a turret. We were impressed the hotel survived the San Francisco earthquake and fires. We knew nothing of the hotel supposedly being haunted. I half awoke one night to experience a feeling like someone was tucking me in and gently pushing on my collarbone. I thought it was a strangely comforting feeling. The next day, we found out the hotel was supposedly haunted by the former headmistress, Mary - who ran a boarding school for girls. We were told she likes to tuck people in at night! I was shocked and a little freaked out by what I’d experienced the night before. It wasn’t a scary experience, it was comforting. I believe it was Mary."

The Queen Anne Hotel is a gorgeous example of its namesake and the fact that it embraces that historic Victorian charm on the interior makes it that much better. One can see the love and effort that Mary Lake took to make this place a home for young girls. This place gave her a lot of pride and losing it was devastating. It wouldn’t be surprising that her spirit would want to return. The question is, did her spirit come back here and does she haunt the hotel? That is for you to decide!